stellablue
DIS Veteran
- Joined
- Oct 14, 2007
- Messages
- 1,332
DISCLAIMER: I am NOT referring to that aweful & ignorant discussion that was out there a while back about "kids not being autistic, they are just being brats" thing
I am strictly talking about doctors MIS-diagnosing.
I am a special ed preschool autism teacher in a large district. I have been working with students with autism for 10 years now-the majority of these students were diagnosed by a neurologist &/or psychologist who ran extensive diagnostic tests to conclude this diagnosis.
Over the past year though, we have been getting a flood of kids with a autism diagnosis entering the preschool. Several of these students' diagnosis has consisted of a 3 sentence letter from a pediatric psychologist diagnosing this child with autism & no documentation to support the diagnosis (test scores, report, etc..). In addition, it is actually always the same specific doctor who is writing these letters. Many of these students exhibit no atypical behaviors, except for communication delays or behavior problems.
In addition, there have been several students in elementary school who are all of the sudden receiving autism diagnoses (from the same doctor in the same format). They were previously diagnosed with ADD or conduct disorder, but now they are all of the sudden autistic. Again, no atypical behaviors except for behavior issues.
My MAJOR concern here is that a child's diagnosis is directly related to their treatment plan. In our district, if you have autism, you enter the "autism program." If you have a conduct disorder, you enter the "behavior program." If you have a mental illness, there is a program for that as well. I sat at a meeting just this week for a second grader who was previously diagnosed with ADD & conduct disorder. Almost grade level academically, no communication/ language issues, age appropriate play skills, typically developing social skills but very severe behavior issues that impeded on his socialization, ability to complete work, & entire day. Poor little guy had such anxiety, low self-esteem, compulsive behaviors, difficulty de-escalating. He lives with his grandmother and brother (brother has mental illness). Nothing pointed to autism with this kid & he would benefit so much from having a school psychologist & a behavior classroom, with staff who could directly work on his behaviors. BUT, this same doctor sent a note in saying "presto! he has autism!" So, now this child is going to enter the special autism program the district offers for students his age. The problem is this program is NOT going to be appropriate for his needs. & it makes me sad for this student because the last thing this student needs is to fail in yet another environment.
As for me, as a preschool teacher in an autism classroom, I feel like the kids who are getting misdiagnosed and receiving autism services are not only not getting their actual needs met, but they are taking time & space away from the children who actually have autism & need these services.
All of these students I am mentioning DO clearly have an impairment of some sort-I am just not so sure they all have autism.
I wish my district had tighter guidelines on what qualifies as an autism diagnosis. I do not feel it is sufficient to accept just a 3 sentence letter from this one doctor with no documentation or test scores to back it up.
In conclusion, I do think that autism is often getting MIS-diagnosed. NOT by parents, but by doctors who don't take enough time to properly screen a child, or see a behavior problem or language issue & immediately classify them as autistic. I am ALL for getting children services, as long as they are the right services to best suit their needs.
Just needed to vent. Please no flames & if you want to respond, please do so respectfully.

I am strictly talking about doctors MIS-diagnosing.
I am a special ed preschool autism teacher in a large district. I have been working with students with autism for 10 years now-the majority of these students were diagnosed by a neurologist &/or psychologist who ran extensive diagnostic tests to conclude this diagnosis.
Over the past year though, we have been getting a flood of kids with a autism diagnosis entering the preschool. Several of these students' diagnosis has consisted of a 3 sentence letter from a pediatric psychologist diagnosing this child with autism & no documentation to support the diagnosis (test scores, report, etc..). In addition, it is actually always the same specific doctor who is writing these letters. Many of these students exhibit no atypical behaviors, except for communication delays or behavior problems.
In addition, there have been several students in elementary school who are all of the sudden receiving autism diagnoses (from the same doctor in the same format). They were previously diagnosed with ADD or conduct disorder, but now they are all of the sudden autistic. Again, no atypical behaviors except for behavior issues.
My MAJOR concern here is that a child's diagnosis is directly related to their treatment plan. In our district, if you have autism, you enter the "autism program." If you have a conduct disorder, you enter the "behavior program." If you have a mental illness, there is a program for that as well. I sat at a meeting just this week for a second grader who was previously diagnosed with ADD & conduct disorder. Almost grade level academically, no communication/ language issues, age appropriate play skills, typically developing social skills but very severe behavior issues that impeded on his socialization, ability to complete work, & entire day. Poor little guy had such anxiety, low self-esteem, compulsive behaviors, difficulty de-escalating. He lives with his grandmother and brother (brother has mental illness). Nothing pointed to autism with this kid & he would benefit so much from having a school psychologist & a behavior classroom, with staff who could directly work on his behaviors. BUT, this same doctor sent a note in saying "presto! he has autism!" So, now this child is going to enter the special autism program the district offers for students his age. The problem is this program is NOT going to be appropriate for his needs. & it makes me sad for this student because the last thing this student needs is to fail in yet another environment.
As for me, as a preschool teacher in an autism classroom, I feel like the kids who are getting misdiagnosed and receiving autism services are not only not getting their actual needs met, but they are taking time & space away from the children who actually have autism & need these services.
All of these students I am mentioning DO clearly have an impairment of some sort-I am just not so sure they all have autism.
I wish my district had tighter guidelines on what qualifies as an autism diagnosis. I do not feel it is sufficient to accept just a 3 sentence letter from this one doctor with no documentation or test scores to back it up.
In conclusion, I do think that autism is often getting MIS-diagnosed. NOT by parents, but by doctors who don't take enough time to properly screen a child, or see a behavior problem or language issue & immediately classify them as autistic. I am ALL for getting children services, as long as they are the right services to best suit their needs.
Just needed to vent. Please no flames & if you want to respond, please do so respectfully.
