When I go to WDW I stay for 7-10 days onsite. I expect CS to not be the greatest but some of these TS places are not good at all for the price. I understand it's Disney and we will pay a markup to eat their but it's getting out of control now. .
I agree with almost everything you said (except we're willing to rent a car). Mostly though, if we're at WDW, eating offsite takes too much time. I've done it. By the time we got back to WDW, it was basically too late to go to a park.
Going to WDW, or any vacation- we're paying a premium just to be there. Air, hotel, park tickets...If we're paying the entrance fee, then we need to maximize park time, within reason.
It's hard to put my finger on all the things that are wrong with WDW food. On several recent trips, WDW food makes us feel slightly ill. The food at US, and the airport didn't bother us. As soon as we ate some place other than WDW, we felt much improved.
A few specific things we noticed is that WDW food tends to be heavily salted. It's hard to get fresh fruit and vegetables. Everything is smothered with sugar, starch and fat. Not just any fat, saturated fats: bacon, butter, and cheese!
Or the menu at the Wave, which was supposed to be healthy. Nearly all the entrees come with cheese, bacon, white flour, potato, and sugar...or a heavy combination of all of the above. Let's see: scallops with bacon/cheese risotto, peach salad with praline (sugar), AND bacon vinaigrette. Lamb with Macaroni and cheese, au-jus. Chicken covered in BBQ (sugar) sauce with fried potato hash, Ravioli covered w/cream sauce.
Another place we walked around in circles was Pepper Market. We could pick pizza (white flour covered in fat ), Roasted pork that was sitting a pool of grease, orange cheese nachos, alfredo sauce pasta, cheese steak, BBQ (sugar)bacon cheeseburger, fries covered in cheese (regular fries aren't bad enough!). This place USED to have a fresh fruit bar! This USED to be one of the very few QS on property that ACTUALLY sold plain, fresh berries!
I mean every place on property, if they serve hamburgers even - they are covered with cheese and bacon. The chicken sandwich isn't just plain with veggies it's covered with "salsa ranch dressing and pepper jack cheese".
Yuck! Do Americans REALLY eat this way ALL the time?!?!?