I noticed many say that in order to save money on food they go off site to eat. Well if you have to rent a car, pay for gas, then the it takes to leave the resort/parks, are you really saving that much money?
We live about 12 hours from Orlando, but fly for convenience and time (Direct flight 2 hours max), we don't rent a car, we just use Disney transportation. We normally stay at the Polynesian, and use the dining plan. By doing it this way, we find we actually save money.
I think its so difficult to compare onsite offsite for food or hotels, the arguments for and against are endless. Just to give one example of dining we love Sweet Tomatoes, good cleen fresh food. 4 adults with vouchers eat there for $28 incl sodas and tax, 4 of us ate at trails end Disney's cheapest buffet $100 with Xmas surcharge and tax. Both + tip.
We have stayed at All stars, totally disliked and AKL, OK for 3 days not somewhere I would stay longer. Disney hotels just don't do it for me, prefer to get offsite away from Disney, just have a more relaxed feel to me, Disney resorts are too big, difficult to explain. Love staying somewhere like Fairfield Inn LBV or Country Inn and Suites, smaller and more enjoyable to me But we have been tempted with free
DDP, Trip in August at OKW we have paid £91/night($135approx) incl DDP for 3 adults, To others this is a bargain, to me I will reserve judgement, offsite we could stay and dine for less last year with the great exchange rate, this year its about the same price but after seeing many reviews and photos of food I am wondering if we have done the right option. Offsite I know we enjoy every meal very cheap, onsite I feel as though we will have to go for more buffets to eat well or pay for extras with regular TS.
There is usually a big difference in a US traveller to UK traveller for time spent there, for us its anywhere between 9 to 25 nights each visit. Personally I would not want to be tied to Disney for 9 nights never mind 25. Maybe if it was 4 or 5 nights that would be different so I would never visit without a car.
Also Internet access annoys me, $10/day onsite free offsite, not looking forward to paying $160 in August for it. Certainly not paying cruise prices for access week after.