Inspired by the Thanksgiving dinner threads...

GeorgeG

<font color=blue>Stumped for 2005<br><font color=r
Joined
Oct 26, 2001
Messages
7,365
I read some interesting Thanksgiving dinner "traditions" and recipes and was wondering how many people have, or know someone with their own "special" recipe for something they swear everyone loves and craves, but in reality can't stand.

I like my meals pretty simple and don't understand why some people must get creative, sometimes to the point of destroying good food.
 
I kind of agree with you. Why MUST we coat our green beans with sodium/fat laden canned soup and canned fried onions on Thanksgiving??

Why MUST sweet potatoes be served in either pie form, or covered with marshmallows?


I am having a tough time deciding what I'm going to eat on T.giving at DBIL's house. His wife is a FABULOUS Italian cook, but literally EVERY sidedish is always covered in butter and/or cream and/or cheese and/or sour cream!! I am going to bring a fairly simple dish of roasted root veggies.... just adding a touch of EVOO and that is it.

Don't get me wrong.... I SO appreciate their hospitality and the fact that she does most of the cooking (since I hate to cook, I am usually the designated soft drink contributor!).... but sometimes simple is nice too.........P
 
I like to at least be able to recognize the food I'm eating - and it drives me nuts when people attach a 6-word title to "stuffing", "broccoli", or some other such thing..

Keep it simple and easily identifiable..:thumbsup2
 
We are pretty simple here as well...the 'traditional' Turkey dinner and all the trimmings is what we have! :)
 

I think every family has someone who is famous for some special casserol that defies recognition... and they insist everyone have some... :confused3
 
We always have a TON of side dishes (I even listed them in the other thread), largely because we have some folks who are casserole lovers, and others who very adamantly do NOT want their veggies disguised. I'm one of the latter. I have always had issues with textures, and there are many foods that I do not care for because of their mouth-feel. Most veggie casseroles are off my list, because I can't tolerate creamy foods that also contain crisp chunks, and I also have a low tolerance for cheese. That said, the four casserole-type dishes that are now de rigeur on our holiday menu are generally liked by a lot of people -- there are never leftovers. (FTR, the four are a spicier variation on the green bean casserole, a broccoli-cheese casserole, Spinach Madeleine, and a sweet-potato/praline souffle. I don't care for any of them.)

When I was a kid my mother was a typical Irish cook -- she either boiled, braised or fried EVERYTHING, and no two foods were ever mixed together except for the addition of butter and/or onions. As my siblings took over hosting holiday meals, casserole-style foods started to creep onto the menu, but the things Mom made also remained. (Mom really wasn't a very good cook overall, but she had a few specialties that she did VERY well, and most of them were either simple veggies or pork dishes.)

When I host, the veggies I make are essentially plain; with nothing but herbs and butter or olive oil added. If other people want to contribute casseroles, I'm fine with serving them, but 90% of the time I won't eat them.

The oddest holiday casserole I ever encountered was made by a boss of mine who invited me to her home the first year that I lived here.
It was some kind of jello mold that contained cinnamon, but it wasn't a dessert.
 
I do not care for any kind of a "salad" that's made with Jello. Paricularly green jello. In my world, Jello is a dessert and not a very good one at that. ;)

No one in my immediate family makes this but it seems like at any extended family party, someone brings this.
 
Well, this isn't really about casseroles for me. But what gets me and others in my family is my mothers "butternut balls". She loves them (and she's the ONLY one that even remotely likes them) LOL But she will continue to make them and ask why anyone won't eat any. But we'll tell her REPEATEDLY how horrible they really are (all in good fun though). They taste like a ball of chalky dust. I know there are other names for them but they escape me right now. But they are putrid!!! :sick:
 
I kind of agree with you. Why MUST we coat our green beans with sodium/fat laden canned soup and canned fried onions on Thanksgiving??

Why MUST sweet potatoes be served in either pie form, or covered with marshmallows?
The thought of both of these makes me shudder. Neither was ever a part of our traditions, thankfully.
I do not care for any kind of a "salad" that's made with Jello. Paricularly green jello. In my world, Jello is a dessert and not a very good one at that. ;)

No one in my immediate family makes this but it seems like at any extended family party, someone brings this.
My MIL made "The Mold" every Thanksgiving, and the rest of the family teased me behind her back because I loved it! :laughing: Haven't had it in years.
 
The thing that actually bugs me is when my DBrother makes his apple pie. He's got a culinary degree, for cryin' out loud, yet he uses those nasty, mushy, syrupy canned apples in his pie!! Ugh, I can't even try to eat it.

'Course, it could just be me; I'm VERY picky about my apples! :rolleyes:
 
My wife watches The Food Network a lot and I can't believe the nasty stuff those "gourmet" chefs invent. I could never be a judge because I wouldn't even put any of it near my mouth. I guess it's all about creating dishes that are new, exotic, colorful and different. If you're sophisticated enough you're supposed to think it's delicious. My attitude is that if it's not broken, don't even try to fix it. At least Emeril admits to being fond of grilled cheese sandwiches.

Presentation is supposed to be so important, too. For me, if it's on the plate, it's presented. I don't need any little twigs or fancy sauce to make it look pretty. Do you suppose my wife is right about me being a boring eater?
 
My wife watches The Food Network a lot and I can't believe the nasty stuff those "gourmet" chefs invent. I could never be a judge because I wouldn't even put any of it near my mouth. I guess it's all about creating dishes that are new, exotic, colorful and different. If you're sophisticated enough you're supposed to think it's delicious. My attitude is that if it's not broken, don't even try to fix it. At least Emeril admits to being fond of grilled cheese sandwiches.

Presentation is supposed to be so important, too. For me, if it's on the plate, it's presented. I don't need any little twigs or fancy sauce to make it look pretty. Do you suppose my wife is right about me being a boring eater?

I'm with you, George..

Sometimes I watch "Top Chef" and I'm thinking to myself, what is that glob on the plate? Then when they describe it, it's even worse! :eek:

Guess I'm a "boring eater" too..;)
 
Add me to the boring list. If I don't recognize it, I won't eat it ;) My mom watches those shows but thank GOODNESS she never tries making that stuff! :crazy2:
 














Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE







New Posts







DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top