I feel like I had a totally different experience than all of you! I've only done it once, earlier this year (Feb), and I really enjoyed it. We were running a bit behind and showed up roughly 15-20 minutes before Illuminations. Had a few desserts, hot coffee and chocolate, and grabbed a table with a great view. I probably didn't get my "money's worth" of food/drink by showing up late but that was my fault. Otherwise I thought it was great and would totally do it again.