I would have to say the Yachtsman Steakhouse, the whole experience was superb, the meal, the service, the whole atmosphere. The steaks were absolutely perfect, it ranks as one of the best meals I've ever had.
It also gave us the opportunity to spend an evening in the Yacht Club, from the 'secret' little bar where the barman rustled up the most amazing champagne mojito's, to strolling round and seeing Stormalong Bay for the first time - I couldn't believe how amazing the whole place was. Suffice to say, the Yacht Club has been pencilled in for my 40th birthday celebrations in a couple of years time!