If you had to axe 3 of the following ADRs-

[aenelson]

1. 50s PT
2. Napoli
3. The Wave

 

[robinb]

I would get rid of:
Raglan Road - The beer is the best part of this place.
50s Prime Time Cafe - Home cooking type food that is worse than my own home cooking. Not a hit with our family.
Le Cellier - Overhyped.

 

[Uncleromulus]

Teppan Edo
Ohana
Prime Time Cafe
Tusker House (honorable mention)

 

[Rhongepooh]

I'd REALLY ax Le Cellier. . . . especially if it's during the week of Thanksgiving. . . . but let me know before you do so I can snag that reservation!

 

[drew64]

I would axe:

The Wave
Raglan Road
Ohana or Teppan Edo

 

[avw1295]

I would keep Teppan Edo and Ohana. They are two of my favorites. We go to both on every trip.

I would axe Le Cellier. I feel that it is overrated. I was not impressed at all.

 

[Euphoria027]

I'd REALLY ax Le Cellier. . . . especially if it's during the week of Thanksgiving. . . . but let me know before you do so I can snag that reservation!

Hahaha, I'm going the first week of January! Sorry!

 

[ZoZo]

I'm not a big fan of Raglan Road. One of the worst meals in my 6+ trips to WDW.

 

[chocovrdmicears]

I would axe:
Raglan Road
The Wave
Ohana - (one of the worst meals we have ever had in 6 yrs of eating @ WDW).
I would definately keep Tusker House if it is for breakfast. If it isn't, I would add it to the list of potentials to axe.

 

[kdfogliano]

I would axe Jiko...
i am sure this will get flames, but had a bad dinner there last time and dont think its a good as it used to be,

KEEP california grill!!!

 

[Pooh&OurHunny]

I guess you have to plan another trip to eat at the other restaurants...
Seriously, I would drop 50's Prime, Raglan Road and Teppan
I think you need to also look at the menus and see what you would order. Happy planning.

 

[catne]

different perspective...I'd axe the signatures! Most signatures we've gone to were not worth the cost, IMO. We were not impressed with Cali Grill at all. It was OK, but nowhere near as good as the prices.

I'd skip Teppan Edo, too...same old food/style you can get outside the World at less cost.

 

[Disneywedding2010]

California Grill was awful, over priced, and the service was terrible.

 

[taymorel]

Raglan Road
The Wave
Tusker House
Teppan Edo
California Grill
50s Prime Time Cafe
'Ohana
Jiko
Via Napoli
Le Cellier

(All lunch/dinner)

Which 3 would you get rid of? I don't care about price or dining plan credits but all other factors can play a part. We have never been to any of these places, so we have no pre-conceived notions about them either.

I would axe 50s Prime Time Cafe and The Wave.


caroline

 

[barbiecruiser]

Ohana in May and July were both amazing for us!! Keep it!

 

[Quin]

OK, so you are looking for dining experiences you cannot get at home in small-town Maine and I am assuming adults only.

I'd drop 50s Prime Time first - you can get better home cooking than this at home. I think the experience is fun and unique for families that for whatever reason don't get to experience old-fashioned home cooking.

I'd drop Raglan Road second - when all is said and done, it's just another chain restaurant. Fun pub atmosphere but you can probably get equivalent food closer to home.

I'd actually suggest you drop Le Cellier as the final choice, just because based on where you live, you can get REALLY good Canadian food. You don't need to come to Florida and waste valuable Disney time (and dollars) on cheese soup. For heaven's sake, you can probably go to Montreal for dinner any day of the week.

If for some reason Le Cellier strongly appeals to you, drop Via Napoli instead. *disclaimer: I have not eaten there*. My perception is that it is good pizza, but only you can decide whether the pizza as described there is 'enough' better than average chain pizza for you to keep this ADR over one of the others.

All this, of course, presupposes that you have listed all these choices not only because they sound 'exotic' to you but also because you would genuinely enjoy the types of food. I would personally drop Tusker house but that's just because the cuisine does not appeal to my personal tastes, not because I think there is anything wrong with it. YMMV.

 

[Quin]

And I personally ADORE dinner at 'Ohana.

 

[TruBlu]

KEEP:
Tusker House
Teppan Edo
Le Cellier

AXE:
'Ohana

Have never tried these:
Raglan Road
The Wave
California Grill
50s Prime Time Cafe
Jiko
Via Napoli

 

[ToddyLu]

My recommendation is...if you decide to drop 50's Prime Time for lunch...at least get the hand dipped milkshake for dessert as you walk around DHS...can get you one at the bar right inside the door. Best milkshakes I believe on property---although I have never been to Beaches and Cream. Plus, you just have to get a peek at the decor. I am 42 and it was like time travel back to my Granny's house.

We are eating at Cali Grill twice our next trip...keep it.

 

[honeydiane1953]

Via, RR, and Jiko