Thanks for all of the feedback! My DH and I are going to be in St. Augustine for a week and I just couldn't be so close and not "stop in" atleast. So I booked a room at OKW for one night (bought 10 one-time use points) ...unfortunately, we do have to get back to the rest of the family in St. Augustine. Shucks!
So I'm trying to make the most of my one dayer...I've never done it for just one day! Since I'm planner of the family, I'm holding back my need to create an excel spreadsheet and lay it all out.

But I would like a general game plan atleast, in my head, so I can make the most of my one day. I do have to keep reminding myself that I have a big trip planned next year at WDW for the whole family AND since I am a member, this isn't my one and only trip ever....it's just so hard!
So far, I'm torn between MK, Epcot and yep - Animal Kingdom. Dinner, I'm leaning towards Liberty Tree Tavern, Ohana and San Angel Inn. It's a dilemma, but you've all given me stuff to think about. Thanks again!