I agree with you. Dd graduated from a very well known private school in Fort Lauderdale with a 5.02 GPA, scored 5 on the calculus AP exam and 4 on the AP Chem exam, yet couldn't score higher than 1450 on the SAT. She is very, very bright and gifted in math, yet just doesn't take standardized tests well. She has taken the pre-entrance tests for her fall engineering courses (they have an engineering prep program) and scored near perfect on the calculus section. If she had scored higher on the SAT she would've applied to Cornell for engineering, but with a 1450 her college advisor said she most likely wouldn't get in (turns out that 15 kids from her school got in this year). Things have worked out perfectly and she did get accepted at her first choice with the largest scholarship they offer, so it is true that everyone ends up where they are supposed to be. Plus she will be only a 3 hour drive from me!