I need some recommendations please

I just discovered upon my internet search that Neutrogena has stopped making their Norwegian forumla moisture wrap body lotion. I'd just thought Target stopped carrying it in store when I didn't see it but since I hadn't needed it I didn't look way back then. So in the next few months I'm going to need a replacement.
Looking for a lotion that's not expensive that's under $20 for a decent size bottle, this one is 15 oz and was around $10. Needs to be unscented and even if it says unscented needs to not smell funny because we all know nothing is really unscented. Also needs to be non greasy/oily. I want to to do it's job, rub in and leave my skin dry because it's rubbed in like it's supposed to. Prefer a lotion over a cream or butter, this is mostly used on my hands and I have stuff for when they get uber dry in the winter/too much hand washing.
I've previously tried vaseline and feel like it's too watery. I think they also had a new type out that I tried in the store and it was greasy and smelled so I had to use a wet one. It doesn't need to be fancy and have all the "new" stuff in it, I'd like something comparable to what I was using. Really sad they stopped making it since I feel like it's closer to the product that they started with than what they are now. I do have other face lotions and stuff I use but they don't have a comparable replacement.