Can I just throw out that one thing I love about this thread is that no one tell's anyone else they are wrong for liking any of the hotels? So often on other threads it feels like people want to jump you if you don't stay Deluxe Club Level every trip

or one hotel is better than another NO MATTER WHAT AND YOU ARE WRONG IF YOU DISAGREE!!
We are Pop fans but biased as it's the first place we stayed (also, I always wanted to stay at one of the All Star resorts for the large Disney figures when I was growing up, and we've always been in the 50s section so I get that with the Lady and the Tramp figures, which is one of my favorite movies

). But we've also loved all of our Swolphin stays, and would probably pay cash OOP over Disney deluxe if the rate was right (vs Disney hotels). We don't spend much time in the room anyways and I think we'd be bad at hanging around enjoying the deluxe hotels unless we didn't have park tickets