So
@Lain, since we were both greeted with the popup on the SPG card, what are your thoughts for picking it up anyway for the referral points and the ongoing FN only? I'm torn a bit as it is definitely my shot to keep a $95 FNC since they're increasing the SPG Biz AF so that's no longer a keeper. But on the other hand I was mostly interested in the bonus to replenish the points we're spending this year and it's kinda hard to reward AmEx's... rude?... behavior with the popup by still getting their product without an incentive. (hard to come up with a Disney word at the moment for how I really feel about them. swinging back to "hate" hard in this love/hate relationship

)
So I go back and forth on should I do it or not if I get the popup again. I mean, my profile with AmEx is an average joe profile really. I can't believe they really want to alienate the masses to discourage a select group's behavior. Being a long time customer with only 2 open products I'd be very confused if I got the pop up not knowing all I know now. I've put spend on the SPG Biz in the last week just in case but I highly suspect this is not strictly a spend problem with this algorithm. I think they're seeing I haven't had the SPG Biz card for a year yet and are limiting how much can be shelled out in one program at one time. My limited spend probably isn't helping me either but I'm not sure what I'll do when I apply again if I see the pop up.
Honestly, for the first time in a long time, I don't know what to do with Amex.
I hit the MSR on my BGR with a charge on 1/31, which was pending and didn't post until 2/4. $200 of the MSR was a PayPal donation to my kiddo's PTO, so I put in extra spend to make up for it, in case that didn't count, before the MSR period ended yesterday. I'm still waiting for the SUB to post, but have a nagging feeling of dread that I might get a no-pop-up-denial. I've opened 8 Amex cards in the past 14 months, so maybe the BGR was tempting fate, but I've been putting thousands in spend across my cards every month, and my overall spend with Amex has actually increased in recent months because of traveling, some unexpected expenses, and the holidays. Most of my Amex SUBs have posted 2-3 days after hitting MSR, but I know there can be some delay for a week or two (like with
@striker1064), and there seems to be a lot of reports of lag with the airline fee credits posting, so I don't know... I hate being in limbo, and I don't want to "call the bank" either.
Since DW's last pop up on the SPG Personal, I threw a $2.6k charge on her Hilton Biz last week on top of an earlier $500 purchase from Staples .com to take advantage of the Amex Offer and no-fee MCGC deal, and have used her SPG Biz to pump gas a few times and small charges here and there. (We're going to try hit $15k spend on the Hilton Biz regardless for the free weekend night.) I'll probably try applying once more next week before the SPG Personal goes away on 2/13. If I don't get the pop up, I'd still be nervous about a no-pop-up-denial. If I get the pop up, I don't know if another 35k FN cert a year from now (and possibly every year after) is enough to tempt me. I was also hoping for the 75k Marriott points to help replenish our stash after having made a big Hawaii redemption for later this year. Between my wife and I, we have 2x SPG Biz, 1x SPG Personal, 1x SPG Lux, 1x Marriott Biz, and 1x MPP. I'll keep our 2x SPG Biz another year because the AF increase won't hit us this year and I'll pocket the 2x 35k FNs (for Disneyland and Universal Studios Hollywood). I'm planning to keep my SPG Personal and SPG Lux too. My Marriott Biz FN has already posted, and I'm going to cancel it when the AF hits (to free up room for more Chase biz cards). I'm seriously considering upgrading my MPP to a Ritz-Carlton after my first year is up. That's 5x 35k FN certs, and 1x 50k FN cert this year. I don't think we need another 35k FN, especially if Marriott is going to move all the good redemptions where we'd actually visit and stay up to Cat. 6. In which case, it makes keeping my SPG Lux and upgrading the MPP to a Ritz-Carlton all the more compelling, since the 50k FNs look to be more useful for us.
I'm much more focused on more Chase biz cards in the coming months. My wife is 1/24, and I'll be under 5/24 again next month. Going to get the United Biz, because my wife could always use more miles and my account needs replenishing, then eyeing another CIP for each of us, and a CIU for me.