There have been a lot of instances where Josh has gone to one park on both a recommended day and a non-recommended day in the same week to compare the crowds and the wait times. He'll document it all with pictures to demonstrate the difference between following his recommendations and not. A lot of times, if TP had something different, he'll address it and from his pictures can prove that he was right. I love how he actually goes into the parks and uses photos to show that he knows what he's talking about. It's amazing what a difference it can make to be in a recommended park. Josh will also go to two different parks in the same day to compare the difference that way. So I would say, easyWDW is more accurate, and he takes the time to prove it in an informative, detailed, and hilarious way.