Agree! I work in a special ed preschool class. When parents want to bring in birthday treats, we ask them to bring unfrosted cupcakes or cookies. Some of our kids are picky eaters and don't even eat sweets. Others are very messy eaters and will smear more frosting, pudding or yogurt than they will eat. It's fine if the parent wants to share a treat and take pictures of their child while we sing Happy Birthday. But with a 15 minute snack period, we don't have time for a full-blown party or meal. And with our two class sessions scheduled back-to-back, we don't have time for extra cleaning. One group eats and leaves while another group is arriving. We have to keep things simple to stay on schedule, keep our kids focused and keep behavior in check.
Although we are not a special ed room, we do have a lot of children with special needs. One of them is currently being evaluated, and another one we need to conference with parents about. We actually have two more (another set of twins, God help us!...that will make two sets in one class!) starting in two weeks, and they will both come with a TSS. Many of our children do not eat the sweet snacks either. We threw out a lot. We had another "party" today, and it was much better....you know what they liked the best? The fruit salad a mom made...and she cut up all the fruit into tiny pieces. It was wonderful! They ate that and left the donut holes on the plate!
Our "party" days are normal, regular days, and we have our "party snack" during the last 15 minutes of the morning. That is our normal snack time. Our time is extremely limited.
As for clean up time...quite frankly, I only get paid for 15 minutes after the children leave. That is my normal "clean up the room" time and get ready for the next day. I am not very happy about spending that time scraping chocolate pudding off of chairs, tables and floors, even if it is only a few times a school year. Thanks, but no thanks.