I have a slight dilemma; any advice would be appreciated.

For us we cook breakfast & dinner. VGF was the better choice since they have grills and they are gas grills (so no lugging charcoal down to grill). Dining options don’t really matter to us. My kids have allergies and while Disney restaurants are good with them, many times it is quicker and less stress to just make safe food ourselves.
 
Time to get real with Disney Choose the location that has the most options for transport cause Disney is changing up to save money …
That is our new real issue… You can walk from BLT or Poly or Grand Floridian to transportation options and resorts or some restaurants Walk with SSR to DIsney Springs … you can walk with BoardWalk locations …
Dont choose anything that can leave you stranded for any resort vacation choice . We need to start factoring this in … along with all
those other important things like Money and maintenance dues and point charts and resale and blue card .
But I admit I love the Riviera and would love to add on . That place is very relaxing .
 
Time to get real with Disney Choose the location that has the most options for transport cause Disney is changing up to save money …
That is our new real issue… You can walk from BLT or Poly or Grand Floridian to transportation options and resorts or some restaurants Walk with SSR to DIsney Springs … you can walk with BoardWalk locations …
Dont choose anything that can leave you stranded for any resort vacation choice . We need to start factoring this in … along with all
those other important things like Money and maintenance dues and point charts and resale and blue card .
But I admit I love the Riviera and would love to add on . That place is very relaxing .

Its why we love it. In terms of transportation, we now plan for and budget in for Lyft during vacations in case we want to give ourselves that option if the Skyliner were to go down vs. having to rely on buses.

Did that in June....Skyliner down...walked to BCV...ordered Lyft....with tip was $10 for our mid day trip back to RIV. Well worth it than walking back to the front of Epcot to catch the bus.
 
What and how exactly is Disney changing up regarding transportation?

Less buses?
 

Sounds like your heart is with Riviera. I would follow your heart. If you never see yourself staying at VGF and making decent use of it, then there's no sense in buying there. If you are okay with staying at SSR at any given time, I would buy there and take advantage of the upfront savings. However, if you love Riviera and would like to stay there on a more regular basis, then you should be eyeing that.

When I inquired about buying direct (recently), RIV didn't include the "Developer Credit" of $2,500 for members (or $1,500 for prospect members) that VGF was given. All other incentives were mutually inclusive to both RIV and VGF. The price difference in a 150-point contract was $2,500/$1,500 depending on whether you are an existing or prospect member. This doesn't seem that great if you take into account the years left on the respective contracts and spread it across the life of the contract. At the end of the day, I think you can justify paying the higher upfront cost of RIV, knowing that you really aren't paying much more. If you are comfortable with the financials with buying VGF direct, it would seem that it would be just as easy to warrant buying RIV.
 
that's why you need to buy multiple resorts or be flexible...

for us being able to walk to the parks is a must... so it's VGF, BLT, BCV, BWV or bust...
It looks like my SSR points can get me into BLT for my travel periods.

It is one reason my daughter wants me to consider BWV as our next contract. I never considered it until now.
 
My advice: rescind. You aren't happy with what you are buying. But, my next advice is: You should buy RIV direct. That's the one you want, so that's the one you should buy.

The resale restrictions do not matter to you, because you are not buying it resale. You might lose a little value on the back end, but that's probably a couple decades from now. The market does not seem to be penalizing RIV more than marginally. And, a couple of decades from now is after 2042, where the Original 14 become the Original Eight And A Half. At that point, I think the "restriction penalty" is going to be even smaller than it is today for valuing a DVC resale deed. At that point, resale owners will be completely shut out of the Epcot area unless they buy at one of those resorts. And, RIV is one of those resorts.

I'm a big dollars-and-cents guy, and am usually the first to jump on the all-resale all-the-time bandwagon. Heck, I'm the guy who might tell you to buy a non-Disney timeshare because DVC doesn't make sense.

But I also think that buying a timeshare is more about changing your lifestyle than it is saving money. I mean, sure you probably can save some money here and there, but that's not really the point. Buying RIV means (a) you will be able to stay at your preferred resort and (b) never having to worry about restrictions. And, the calendar is moving to a point where everyone is going to have to start thinking about what restrictions mean for them before too many more years pass.
This! As Brian says, the resale restrictions will not impact you except for sale price. If this is where you want to stay, rescind and flip it to Riviera.

You mention being out of state annual pass holder. How many are you purchasing each year? Do you purchase each year? We have a family of four and saved ~$1,700 this year compared to the out of state rate.

We know the benefits are not guaranteed, but resale vs direct we went direct VGF (all four of us agree it is our favorite resort) as it will only take a few years of passes to even out (by my VGF math it was 5 years). It is a gamble but feel it is a pretty safe one that the cheaper annual pass with remain available (at least with renewals).
 
The Only perk worthwhile for the blue card holders are the AP pass discounts. If you don't need the AP discount, then cancel the direct buy and purchase SSR resale. If your heart is set on staying at RIV some years, you could rent out your SSR points and then transfer in RIV points. However, you are set on RIV every year as an option, then stay with your direct buy because resale points effective post 2019 (June I think) cannot be used RIV or non legacy resorts going forward, so far it is only RIV and The new dvc in CA
 
So, my first world problem is wondering if I should just rescind my purchase with Disney directly and go purchase a resale contract.

I recently purchased (within the last 3 days) a 150 VGF contract directly from Disney. I really wanted Riviera but just couldn't justify the resale restrictions on it, so I stuck with VGF. Well, I was looking at the resale market and I can buy a 200-point SSR contract much cheaper and with way more points. I know the deed expires way sooner and SSR is typically considered the "resort of last resorts", but I don't really care about every staying at VGF. The resort isn't really my style. I'm okay with SSR as a home resort and then having options at different resorts at the 7-month window. I feel like VGF as a home resort is kind of useless for me, between the point costs of the room and the resort itself.

However, with that being said, I wonder how much I will regret not being a "blue card member" for not buying direct.
Just curious if anyone else has similar thoughts.
If blue card perks aren't an issue, you may want to consider 2 resale contracts. But the SSR, and buy a smaller Riviera one as well.
 
When in doubt, RESCIND THE DIRECT. They will be happy to redo it for you next week or six months from now. If you aren't sure, RESCIND NOW.

The dates and what you are booking matter a lot for whether SAP will work for you. I travel off peak, mostly 1BRs, and SAP work great for me.
 
Time to get real with Disney Choose the location that has the most options for transport cause Disney is changing up to save money …
If what you are saying is true (which I don't see any actual evidence for given their massive efforts to run all of the buses), then the obvious outcome is to connect the Skyliner to the monorail. That line would be HS -> Coronado Springs -> TTC, IMO. It would put a massive cash resort/convention center with room to expand on the skyliner and the monorail and eliminate buses for everything but AKL for a ton of resorts. And there's an empty space north of Coronado and south of TTC. IMO, that move would make Poly by far the best location in all of WDW. Or maybe Disney plans to have self-driving buses anyway and none of this will matter.
 
When in doubt, RESCIND THE DIRECT. They will be happy to redo it for you next week or six months from now. If you aren't sure, RESCIND NOW.

The dates and what you are booking matter a lot for whether SAP will work for you. I travel off peak, mostly 1BRs, and SAP work great for me.


I am hoping SAP ends up working great for us also. The plan is either the 16th through 31st of January or August. If I get enough points the "or" might change to "and"

I was able to book at BLT at under 4 months for our August trip.

I thought about Riviera resale, but I think I would end up losing points or having to buy points at 7 months to make it work.

In August I will take my wife and daughter to Poly2 area, Riviera and Boardwalk so they can give me their opinion on what they think we should buy. Including BLT that would give them 4 to select 1.

Riviera and Poly2 would be direct. Boardwalk or BLT would be resale.
 
In August I will take my wife and daughter to Poly2 area, Riviera and Boardwalk so they can give me their opinion on what they think we should buy. Including BLT that would give them 4 to select 1.

Riviera and Poly2 would be direct. Boardwalk or BLT would be resale.
Yep this is me, well, I'm not really considering BWV but I do want poly 2 direct if it ends up being separate association along with resale BLT and CCV.
 



New Posts

















DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top