HP Fanclub (Part 2!)-Have yourself a Cauldron Cake & join in the discussion!

It was like a shock. You were like "WOW" when you read it. And the thing about Snape being the one to tell Lily about the Dementors instead of James like you though. The entire 7 book was like.....wow......

that's why i loved it.
:]


except of the bonus chapter.
i found it kinda cheesey.
i mean, it was useful, but i felt like jo was in fanfic mood or something.
that's just me though...
 

that's why i loved it.
:]


except of the bonus chapter.
i found it kinda cheesey.
i mean, it was useful, but i felt like jo was in fanfic mood or something.
that's just me though...

I sorta liked the bonus chapter.
It was a nice wrap up to everything.
Although the name of Ron and Hermione's kids turned me off.
And the last word wasn't scar...how disappointing!
 
I sorta liked the bonus chapter.
It was a nice wrap up to everything.
Although the name of Ron and Hermione's kids turned me off.
And the last word wasn't scar...how disappointing!


The way the bonus chapter was written was geinus. By putting it 19 years in the future stopped anyone from trying to contuine it.

The name Rose was awesome. It was Hugo that scared me. Why Hugo?!?!?!? That poor kid. Scorpius is going to tease him.
 
The way the bonus chapter was written was geinus. By putting it 19 years in the future stopped anyone from trying to contuine it.

The name Rose was awesome. It was Hugo that scared me. Why Hugo?!?!?!? That poor kid. Scorpius is going to tease him.

Yea is Scorpius doesn't get teased into insanity first! :rotfl:
 
Scorpius...What a HORRIBLE name for a child.

It's not as bad as Albus Severus though. *barf* They're both good names, but together it's horrrrible.
 
The epilogue was so cliche and predictable.
I was really really disappointed.
 
I'd prefer she left it open for the readers to decide what became of Harry's future.
Rowling is generally so unexpected and unique in her writing. And she was never the whole "perfect happiness and rainbow and butterflies" kind of author.
I found the epilogue to be extremely dull and a total cop-out.
 
I'd prefer she left it open for the readers to decide what became of Harry's future.
Rowling is generally so unexpected and unique in her writing. And she was never the whole "perfect happiness and rainbow and butterflies" kind of author.
I found the epilogue to be extremely dull and a total cop-out.


But if she did that people would be trying to write continuing books about Harry. This stopped people from making a profit off of her idea.
 
Honestly, I was really let down with the epilogue.
But, with all of these books she's given us, and the story she created.
I forgive her. :D

And it's her book, so she can do as she pleases.
 
I'd prefer she left it open for the readers to decide what became of Harry's future.
Rowling is generally so unexpected and unique in her writing. And she was never the whole "perfect happiness and rainbow and butterflies" kind of author.
I found the epilogue to be extremely dull and a total cop-out.

i totally agree with everything you said.
i was kinda upset when i read it.
but you know, after seven books that amazed me since i was like... young, i'll let it slide.
 
I'd prefer she left it open for the readers to decide what became of Harry's future.
Rowling is generally so unexpected and unique in her writing. And she was never the whole "perfect happiness and rainbow and butterflies" kind of author.
I found the epilogue to be extremely dull and a total cop-out.
Preach on, sister Mickey!
 





Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE









DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top Bottom