He's just going to have to find a different therapist to find out WHAT this is. Is it anorexia? Coming up to bulemia (since he binges but isn't yet purging)? Is it OCD? Is he just a jerk? Is this just an overreaction from someone who doesn't want to be heavy again? Gotta find out WHAT it is.
Of course you can certainly leave before that happens. The only decision is what you want to do right now...support him in finding a new therapist as well as a couples therapist to help you both communicate in better ways...or just leave?
You need to find a different therapist. You have aright to shop around for the right fit. There are so many different types of therapies and different personalities of people. Just like you & BF naturally get along with some people better than others, the same thing happens with a therapist.
BF needs one who can meet him at his level and work from there. Not all of them will require him to be more emotional than he is.
Definitely. If my therapist had required me to burst into tears at every session and have major breakthroughs, it would have been exhausting.
I won't comment on the emotional side of the relationship, since that is strictly between the two of you. However, I felt like I could add a little perspective from someone who has been in the same position as your boyfriend. Five years ago, I was significantly overweight - (5'6", 240 lbs). I've managed to lose and keep off a little over 85 pounds since then through nothing but diet and exercise, so I can understand where he is coming from. When you have lived a good portion of your life overweight, and are finally able to get fairly healthy, you live every day fearing that one bad decision will cause you to fall off the wagon, so to speak, and the weight will just find its way back to your body; it would be like all of that hard work and sacrifice was for nothing. People in that position can't just be happy that they've lost the weight, they feel like they have to do everything they can to make sure they don't put it back on. So what you see as being obsessive, I see as him making sure he makes the right choices. For instance, you may think it is a problem to think about Friday's meal on Tuesday. But to me and others who have decided to live a healthy lifestyle after years of being unhealthy, that's just proper planning. Why end up eating a 1000 calorie meal when there are 500 calorie options available? You just might not know which are the better options until you are able to research them a bit. I certainly wouldn't just have the knee-jerk reaction of saying that he is OCD. I would say that he's making a conscious effort to make the right food choices, day in and day out.
Let me ask you this. Let's say instead of him being overweight, he recently found out that he has some sort of food allergy. Would you fault him for sending you menus and figuring out what he can eat ahead of time in that situation? Would you consider him OCD if he was constantly looking for new foods that he can eat that wouldn't trigger his allergy?
I'm prepared to get blasted for this, but honestly some of the responses here disappoint me a little bit. I've read that he'll end up anorexic, is OCD, needs to go to therapy for this. Why? Because he was sick of being overweight and wants to live a healthy lifestyle? Because he is thinking about what he puts in his body? Because he wants to make sure that he eats at a restaurant that offers healthy options instead of just sitting down and hoping for the best? You know the old saying, an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure? That's what this sounds like to me. He's doing a little legwork ahead of time to prevent further health problems down the road.
I will say, though, that he needs to find a happy middle point. It took me a few years, but I've gotten to the point where I can enjoy a nice meal out with friends and not worry about what it'll do to the scale. But the next day, I'm back to counting calories and sweating to the oldies, because I know that's the only way I'm going to see my kids and grandkids grow up.
Those are actually good points.
to further the food allergy problem...instead of people thinking about peanuts and anaphalaxsis, what about DS and DH's problems with corn syrup based products? We accidentally bought something with the cutesie-named "corn sweetener" (our local Great Harvest Bread Co is using it instead of honey, isn't that lovely?), and before I figured it out, I got to have a full weekend of two people who were unbearable. DS had tantrums that he doesn't have anymore, hubby got so annoyed and angry, just over the top, about it, we had to talk to DS about his unacceptable behaviour multiple times on Sunday, and so on. On late Sunday I looked at the label, and called the store, and yep, it's HFCS.
So that doesn't kill a person, but it sure does make the spouse/mother kinda want to send them away!
So we sound obsessive in listing out the items they can't have. NOw we get to add corn sweetener to the list. We *have to* ask, talk about it, think about it, etc etc etc, in order to help DS and DH. (interestingly, DH's blood sugar was fine...but that's likely because it was *cinnamon* bread, and cinnamon is the wonder drug to beat all wonder drugs for hubby's blood sugar..it covered up the spike he would have had, but he was absolutely unbearable, mood-wise, for two days)
So now does it sound a bit more "normal", one end of normal for sure, but possibly just a variation. The problem is, he needs to keep it in his head a bit more.
I can't live with him making ME feel bad because of the way HE feels. That's not fair.
So that makes me feel like he's blaming me for the food he eats.
Does *it* make you feel like that, or does HE make you feel like that? Is that his intent? Or is it paranoia? I've had that, for sure, I've felt like DH saying something *about* me, when he's only talking *to* me. And I've done it to DH, too. His weight is a big issue, he's having a horrible time getting it down (pituitary tumor, awful, so hard to lose weight when dealing with this nonsense), and he grew up with a mother that plated his food, forced him to eat it all, and then shamed him for gaining weight. She also wouldn't let him run and play and hop and skip like normal kids, because she was afraid of him getting hurt. he was in a lose lose lose lose and then gain weight situation, and the physical AND emotional effects have lasted and lasted. It was the gift that just keeps on giving from her...
So we can accidentally make each other feel bad. And when I managed to mess up with how I'm talking, I wish he'd understand that I'd never do it on purpose. In fact, the time that I did have to talk to him seriously about his weight, I tried to be as gentle, non-shaming, concerned-about-him as possible. I was crying while talking, that's how difficult it was for me to talk to him. And I should realize that HE would never make fun of ME, too.
So is it just the talk that causes you hurt feelings, or is he deliberately shaming you? I'm not talking about what he said about attraction...that's OK in my book. Right now one of hubby's oldest friends is considering dumping his girlfriend of 2+ years because she's putting on weight. He would actually rather dump her for made up reasons, than take the risk of her anger when he says that she needs to lose a few sizes for him to be attracted to her again. He likes and probably loves her...but he wants her to get her weight back under control for the attraction to be stronger again. And I can totally understand that, having been there most definitely! So talking about weight, even if it hurts to know that you've gained, isn't a heinous crime IMO...(but leaving because of it, without giving any warning, is!).
But you can talk about weight or you can purposely shame a person.
I would leave him because of what I bolded above. Men who love women love them for themselves, not because they are 20 pounds lighter. What happens if you gain a pound, he's less attracted to you and loves you less?
I'd dump him and move on. You're better than that.
Wowie! Very unrealistic, very fairy tale. One can *love* without *attraction*. If one is a very visual person, that can easily happen. DH talks a good game about how his feelings for me don't change. But then I lose 10 pounds, and he's saying vavavavoom all over the place. Mmmhmm, your feelings don't change, yeah right. And it was worse for me as DH was gaining. Though a lot of it was concern for him. One shouldn't pass out 2 seconds after lying down, sleep all night, get up and ready and get on the bus, pass out for the commute, fall asleep while on the phone with customers (that happened twice), leave work, get on the bus, pass out again, get home, have dinner, sit on the couch and pass out again. This is NOT healthy. Especially not in a 33 year old. And it went hand in hand with his weight gain. (this was all years before his blood sugar problems were evident...he had perfect blood sugars and shocked his doctors...but he was requesting bloodwork to check his hormones, and doctors were REFUSING, but we now know it was the prolactinoma starting and making its presence known, and anyone could have found it if they'd just honored his bloodwork requests...it was a sign of a problem, and my noticing it then was GOOD...he was also eating HFCS in lots of things...WW meals, he would have sodas, etc, and passing out cold is something that happens to him with HFCS, just after being nasty and rude.)
I *had to* speak up, and I had to be honest (because that's who I am). Did it hurt his feelings? yes. Was I trying to hurt his feelings? No. I was trying to help him back to health AND help our marriage by bringing the attraction back AND eventually help him feel better about himself.
he would be more attracted to me if I was thinner
Right...that's not saying he would LOVE you more if you were thinner, but that his eyes would be happier.
That's not a crime, IMO.
But bottom line, he needs to find a better therapist, to either stop any problem that's started, or at the VERY least get him to not say everything that's in his head about food. If he IS trying to shame you, and if he wants to stay with you, he has to stop shaming you.
And you have to decide if you want to stick around for this process.