I only request a garden view because that is all we can afford. I dont expect to be upgraded either and have never asked. We have stayed in Niue (smoking), only picked this when it used to be non smoking as it was the closest to the gch, stayed in aeorotora, our view there was of the monorail and parking lot. I didnt request this, it was the only thing available. Last time we had samoa, we had room 1602, ground floor pool view, this was considered a garden view. I have never stayed in tokelau, but see other posters like it alot. It depends what you want. We wanted samoa to be close to the pool , as one of our ds has asthma and I wanted him to be able to get back to the room asap, if he needed to be hooked up to the machine , and its a hop, skip and jump to captain cooks for snack and mug runs. You can look at tikimans site for some great info.