We've dined there twice (October 2006 & December 2007), and we enjoyed it.
My friend loves to try everything, and they had a good variety of things. Her favourite was a dinner roll with stuff in it. Don't ask me what--I'm the "plain" food person! She enjoyed most of what she tried. There were a few things she didn't particularly like.
I'm picky. Plain, well-prepared food served at proper temperature. I'm not fond of WDW salads in general, and this was no exception. Too much stuff mixed together or with dressing, and the "baby greens" looked like the weeds that grow in my yard. Now, I know they aren't, but they look the same. Since I have an ongoing, year-round battle with said weeds, eating something that looks like them has absolutely no appeal!
That said, they had prime rib and turkey at the carving station. Salmon was prepared nicely--some herbs on it, but they were okay. I just don't like stuff that is spicy or competes with what I am eating. There were about four veggies I liked--something in a sauce, but I tried a little and discovered I liked it. I'll be a little adventurous when I can try just a little bit of something and isolate it on my plate. Excluding dessert, there were a good dozen or so dishes that I enjoyed, and I liked a couple of the desserts. I'm not a big dessert person, so that's pretty good!
A three-year-old has nothing on this picky-eater! *LOL*