How can admissions really know that? Unless you are from a large city how can you understand what it's like if you are the admissions counselor in a small place. Vice Versa do we expect someone from a large city to understand the small town politics sometimes of a child getting a job. They are going to look at what is on the application. No one is going to sit back and say uhhhh it's a small town and this child didn't work because it was difficult to get a job. I know it's harsh but it's the truth.
I know it is, but I can't help but think it sucks. Our kids are expected to go to school, have enough extracurriculars to show they're well-rounded, volunteer to demonstrate character, and work too... and that's just to get into the school of their choice, not even to get scholarships! Both of my older kids regularly put in 10+ hour days between school, homework, and activities, and it is rather a kick in the teeth to read that without adding a job on top of all of that they'll be at a disadvantage when applying to selective schools (which will really only matter to DD, DS is pretty sure he's trade school bound).
My child works because I want her to understand what work is. I do not want an entitled child that gets everything paid for and graduates from a great university but then does not now how to take care of herself. My Mother was in admissions in a good solid University. I have heard some stories. I think every high school person should have some job at least in the summer. There ARE jobs, they just might be not a necessarily fun thing. I refuse to believe if your child has all of these contacts through her activities she can find SOMETHING of a job. At the very least babysitting? What about Camp Counselor, swimming guard, landscaper, restaurant etc. When I was 17 I worked at my church making dinner for the priest. Get creative you can find something. I once got paid to do laundry and walk dogs.
I don't think kids who don't work as teens are destined to become entitled brats or unable to care for themselves when they leave the nest. That's an issue that goes much deeper, IMO. But it honestly wouldn't have crossed my mind to put things like babysitting and yard work on a college app. That, to me, feels like a SAHM itemizing all her household management skills on a resume... Forced padding to make up for a lack of substance rather than anything indicative of true experience, achievement, or skills.
As far as whether there are jobs, that's another truly regional thing. There's not a huge market for dog walkers, housesitters, cooking, yard help, etc. in our community, median income $39K. People do those things themselves, count on family, or do without. And a surprising number of jobs that were mostly staffed by teens when I was a kid are closed to minors now. Our town recently eliminated lifeguards thanks to budget cuts, but last year the help-wanted ad specified 18+. Places that serve alcohol (which is pretty much every restaurant in our town other than McDs and DQ) have started requesting 18+ even for busboys and dishwashers. Anything that involves tools, driving, or caretaking does the same, I assume for liability reasons?
The kids whose pretend apps we were looking at did all the above, multisports and pt job. One student did put that he babysit his siblings after school and the admissions people said that helped with his app, so they knew what he was doing with his time. It showed responsibility. He also took AP classes. He was the one our group waitlisted. They said they would rather see volunteer work than no work. They also said they prefer to see longevity in activities, not quantity. Like dont do yearbook for a year, than the paper etc, from sophomore year on they should have one activity that they are dedicated to, now that doesnt mean they cant enjoy other things but they wanted to see them progressing in one of them. I found the seminar fascinating.
I would have too. Good information to know because I wouldn't even have thought to tell DD to mention babysitting or other work within our family on an application because that's just something I assume all kids do. Both my older kids work for FIL, who is a fishing guide, during the summers, washing his boat and gear. But I've never considered that a job because there's no schedule and no real obligation - he doesn't care when they come, as long as some time between when he comes in off the water and dark the boat gets cleaned and prepped for the next morning. But it does pay them enough that they can budget their own spending money through the school year so I guess it is a job of sorts.
It is nice to hear that longevity in activities counts for something. DD is now a volunteer/leader's helper in a 4H garden program that she started out as a participant in when she was in kindergarten, and is starting to narrow her sports dabbling to a couple that she really enjoys. She's a kid who wants to try everything but got that out of her system early and is starting to narrow her focus now as she looks ahead to high school and college.
Where I live, the rate of pay is also pretty high for teens. They can make between 9 and 12 dollars an hour, depending on the job.
Nice.

A lot of adults in my community don't earn that! That would certainly make some sacrifices for the sake of work more attractive. Most teen jobs in my area pay minimum wage ($7.40) or a bit less (ie cash work like babysitting).
And frankly, a good part of it is that we are selfish. We happen to like to do weekend family activities. Summer jobs get in the way of our family time. Our kid had to work over the 4th of July weekend. Really put a damper on our long weekend plans.
That's part of it for me as well. We're fortunate - our 16yo still mostly likes hanging out with us and wants to be part of family vacations. He has very little free time between school, band, and football, however. His summer vacation this year was two non-consecutive weeks without football (the rest of the summer is two-a-day speed training and weights, Mon-Fri) and a job would seriously eat into our ability to spend that time as a family. It has gotten so crazy since he started high school that we aren't even going to spend our whole travel budget this year; we just don't have enough time when we can go away together any more!