Online information has been very confusing about obtaining a Florida Id Card while still retaining an out-of-state Drivers License.
This thread showed up repeatedly in my searches for information on obtaining a Florida Id Card as a 'snowbird' Florida property owner, so I wanted to post some current information as I learned it Nov 2011-- hopefully it helps someone else in the same situation. THIS IS JUST MY EXPERIENCE, FOR WHATEVER IT IS WORTH. I have just been very frustrated by sketchy information online, and am trying to correct outdated info.
I wanted to obtain a Florida Id Card showing my Florida address AND keep my out of state Drivers License (for insurance and vehicle registration purposes). I read many online discussions of how it can be done, I gathered the required documentation listed on the Florida state 'Gather Go Get' website, I went to my local Florida Licensing Bureau. At the licensing bureau I was told that getting a FL Id Card would invalidate my out of state drivers license because of a national registry that now only allows ONE State Id card or Drivers License per individual. I immediately walked out and called a friend in the local Sheriff's office to confirm this. He checked and confirmed that this is TRUE.
Upshot: it was explained to me that as of 2009, new national rule changes affected Florida's practices. Currently, (Nov 2011) if you obtain a Florida Id Card or Florida Drivers License, that information goes into a national database and 'overrides' (invalidates? expires?) your Drivers License from any other state. The same thing would likely happen in any other state; the most recent DL or state Id Card invalidates any active DL or Id Card from any state. You do not even have to 'surrender' a physical drivers license/card; it is an automated system. It is conceivable that the staff at the Florida Licensing Center could simply issue snowbirds a new Florida Id with no warning about this repercussion. I am grateful that they warned me-- I would have continued carrying and using my out of state Drivers License without knowing it had been made invalid.
Apparently, Florida USED TO offer 'temporary' drivers licenses, and 'Florida Only' drivers licenses/Id Cards for part-time or temporary residents. They do not any longer, and that change is not well documented on any official Florida website. In my opinion, this is where much of the misinformation about these Florida Id Cards comes from. Many people DID get them in the past with no issues, but following that same practice today could cause you big problems.
Hope this is helpful. Thanks.