We have stayed at both hotels within the past year.
We stayed at the DT in September 2002 and the rooms are in definite need of renovation. The bathroom was the worst with peeling paint, mildew on the ceiling, loose fixtures. The staff was friendly, the breakfast buffet at the restaurant (can't remember the name) was very good. The pool area was nice, we went one time and had to leave right away due to a severe storm. We did take the bus to DTD one time at night, the seats are a lot more comfortable than Disney's buses. As for transportation to the theme parks, we never used it. If you go with young children, I think it's better to have your own transportation. The buses take too long and are often crowded, also the same bus stops at every DTD hotel.
We stayed at the RP in December 2002 and initially we had some problems. We stayed in the wing area and the carpet in that room was wet.

Not sure what that was about, but we called the front desk right away and were given another room. The second room was fine with no problems and the carpet was dry.

The staff was friendly, especially at the Giraffe Cafe (name ?). Their breakfast buffet was fine, not as good quality as the DT's buffet. The kids enjoyed their Mickey Waffles. We never used the pool at the RP, it was cold, but it looked nice.
I would definitely stay at the RP again and we'll be doing so next week. This time we upgraded to a tower room. As for the Doubletree, I don't think I would stay there again. At least not until the hotel is renovated.
