Thought maybe I should detail my hotel stays.
First trip - Lady Luck. Didn't know any better. We were going to stay on the strip but waited too long to book rooms, and wouldn't you know it there was a big convention with hundreds of thousands of people and all the rooms on the strip were majorly expensive. I'm talking rooms at Circus Circus that had been $49 were now $199. So we decided what the heck, we'd stay downtown. Ugh. Room was terrible. The bathroom was tiny, and the lighting was a bare lightbulb. We half expected to see a chalk outline on the floor. The food was terrible, the area was awful. Parking was across the street and we often had to literally step over drunks. Never again.
Since then:
Bally's - they were in the midst of upgrading and I think we got one of the new rooms. Decor was very nice, room was very comfortable and pretty spacious. Food wasn't that great, but we actually wrote a letter of complaint several months later because the service had been so bad it still bothered us, and the dining manager responded with a very generous food credit for us that we used on a subsequent trip. That time we had excellent service and the food was very good. Because we had the voucher we were treated like VIPs, and had someone at the table every 5 minutes to check on our dining experience. It got to the point where those around us were starting to stare at our table, wondering who we were! Casino was pretty good to us too. I'd definitely stay there again.
Treasure Island - twice actually. I really enjoyed staying there. Room was very nice, nicely decorated and quite comfortable. Lobby was nice. Casino was pretty good. Buffet was terrible. The pool area is pretty standard. But since they've decided to spice up their image, I don't even like setting foot in the casino. Their management has taken a turn for the worse with this new marketing ploy, and it's backfiring big time. They seem to have skimmed the internet and noticed that people online shorten the name to "TI" when referring to it, without realizing that no one actually SAYS "TI" when talking about it. So they changed the name to reflect the hip, current online trend. Real smart. The new "sirens" show sucks. They don't look like entertainers, they look like badly dressed hookers. The could have kept the whole pirate theme and just made the casino a little more adult, that would have done the job nicely.
NYNY - I'm really glad we had a free room here, because first of all I don't think I would have booked here otherwise. I also don't think I'd book there again. The room was okay, had all the things you'd expect for a room. It was decorated in the most horrid colour scheme though - early colour-blind I'd say. Rich wood tones and vibrant purple, with animal prints. Our room had a wonderful view of the pool area (nothing to write home about) and the roller coaster. The casino itself had a really funky smell to it - kind of a combination of stale cigar smoke and musty water. The fast food area is very cool though. Oh, and I didn't like the time share salesmen continually leaping out at you on the second floor.
Monte Carlo - definitely my favourite. Pretty much everything was done right in this place. The only exception to this is that there's no furniture in the massive marble lobby, so you can't just send one person to check in while the other sits and waits. The rooms were very nicely decorated, I loved the shampoo/conditioner in the rooms (Gilchrist and Soames? Something like that). Some have complained about the walls being thin, but I didn't find hear any noise from other rooms. OTOH at Treasure Island I did hear the room beside us once, were two guys had a hired escort in the room and were being rather loud and ... descriptive. Took several calls to security to get that dealt with. But back to the MC... the casino itself is very comfortable - not too dark, not too bright. The food is quite good. It's pretty much everything you could want in a property.
Las Vegas Hilton - Stayed here earlier this year, staying there again in December and possibly in October as well. I don't normally like to stay at one place so many times in a row, but they had a great deal in February (slot tournament including room at a good price), a good rate for December and a great spa package deal that I'm tempted to book for October. The room was really nice - we were located right next to the elevators and the check-in clerk wasn't sure we'd like the room. He though the noise from the elevators might be too much. We barely heard them. Room was huge, the closet was HUGE. You could have set up a cot in the closet. Bathroom was nice. Casino was pretty good, food was okay (they have the only buffet I know of in Vegas that includes wine and beer in their dinner buffet price). Saw Trent Carlini, The Dream King (Elvis impersonator) there and was mightily impressed. Given that we already have a trip back booked, I'd definitely stay there again.