Ok, So I'm not crafty AT ALL, but this is what I did... we went to Hobby Lobby and bought wooden door hangers and we also bought wooden Cinderella carriages (already made and painted)
I had my DF spray paint the door hangers Cinderella blue. Then we glued the carriage to the bottom of the door hanger. They also carry "paint markers" Which is basically just a sharpie that can write on wood, but looks like paint when it dries. We took the paint markers and wrote our name and the wedding date on them! HTH!