Horrible Experiance with DCL - Please be aware!

belu

Earning My Ears
Joined
May 6, 2001
Messages
61
My reason for posting this is to provide information to others about what happened to my family from our perspective. It is not my desire to start a debate about what should or should not have happened, right or wrong in this case. This was a last minute trip, and we were blindsided by what happened. My goal is to prevent this from happening to others and sharing advice about what we did.

My husband, myself, and our 22-month-old son planned a last minute trip to WDW/DCL. My husband is starting a new job on January 15th and will not have an opportunity to take a vacation for at least a year. We have been fortunate and have been to WDW five times in the past 4 years. We took a 4-day cruise on the Disney Wonder in 2000 during our honeymoon trip.

On Friday January 2, 2004 I called to book a land and sea package with air. I was told that it was too late to book air or the land portion through DCL I would need to do that separately. I agreed and booked the 3 day cruise, departing January 8, 2004. I booked separate lodging at the Wilderness Lodge for arrival January 5, 2004. I booked airfare on frontier. I was told by DCL that I would receive my documents at the Port since there was no time to send them.

We arrived at the Wilderness Lodge and had a very nice time. On January 7, 2003 at 6:30 PM we went to Akershus for dinner. I ate three items that my husband and son did not have, 1) peppered herring, 2) tuna salad, 3 )sausage plate. Not long after eating my stomach felt upset and I decided that Norwegian food was not for me. We skipped the fireworks and went back to the hotel because we had to be ready at 1045 AM for the cruise line bus. We made arrangements to complete our documents then. By 10PM we went to bed and I felt the sudden urge to vomit. I did, fortunately in the bathroom. My stomach was still upset but I felt better. I went to sleep again. 11:30PM I wake up run to the bathroom again. Vomit again. Plus now extreme diarrhea. I won’t get any more graphic then this, but I would wake up again at 2:30 AM with more of the same. For me this was not a case of food that did not agree with me, overeating, or anything else I have experienced before. In the span of 5 hours that night, I completely emptied my digestive system. For anyone who has had emergency medical training, what happened to me is what I imagine happens to someone who takes activated charcoal. A complete flush of the system. At some point in the bathroom that night I decided that I was not paying for this meal. I’ve had bad meals at Disney before that made me sick, but never anything like this.

The next morning I woke up dehydrated but feeling better. I called around for a while to find out how to remove the Akershus food portion from our bill. I did not want the server’s tip refunded, as it wasn’t her fault. Finally I reached guest claims. I wasn’t sure what “guest claims” was but after speaking to them briefly it sounded like it was for guests who were making legal claims against the resort like food poisoning, slip and falls etc. I told the woman that I didn’t want to make a claim I just wanted the charge removed from my bill. This was my first mistake. I knew that I had food poisoning, but I didn’t want to make a big deal out of it. I had been a criminal investigator for 5 years, I assumed this was difficult to prove and all I really wanted was to be refunded and get on with my vacation. The claims person put me in touch with the manager of claims and she asked me several questions about where and what I ate all day. Everything I had that day was on property and she seemed to indicate the possibility of a grilled chicken salad I had at whispering canyon as another possibility. After talking to her for about 15 minutes, she agreed that it sounded like the cause was something I ate and she told me that my request for a refund on the food portion of my bill was reasonable and she would have it credited to my room.

We packed up our things and I ate a small amount of oatmeal and drank some water. We went to the lobby to wait for the cruise line bus. I sat in the lobby near the kids TV area with our 22 month old son. I laid down on the couch and the cruise line person arrived. My husband told her about the food poisoning and that I was not feeling well. She gave us our documents and my husband filled them out. By the way, I did not feel any other symptoms like flu, fever, chills, aches. I had a flu shot this year. Colorado got hit hard with the flu and even with the shot, I had the flu in November. Having a young child in daycare, we pass illness back and forth in our family regularly, but we were all in very good health prior to Akershus.

After filling out our forms the cruise line person gave my husband a notice about illness and informed me that I would need to meet with the ship doctor to be cleared for travel. This did not seem to be a very big deal and she told us not to worry about it. After getting on the bus another cruise line person supervisor type told us I would need to be cleared by the doctor but that it would move us to the front of the line.

The ride to the port was very bumpy. My stomach was uneasy. We arrived at the port checked in and I was told I would be meeting with the nurse. They took me to a private room and the nurse entered. She asked me about my symptoms and I told her about Akershus and the events that night, vomiting diarrhea. The nurse without laying a single hand on me informed me that I would be quarantined for 48 hours and that would ruin my trip so they were denying passage.

Okay, I definitely lost my cool here. This was the beginning of a 2.5 hour ordeal. I asked why and was told that any passenger who has vomiting and any other symptom would be quarantined. Here’s why I was so mad at this point.

1) No physical information was taken from me. Temperature, pulse, allergy history, blood pressure.
2) My impression from cruise line personal was that the doctor needed to see me to make a determination if my illness could be attributed to something other then Norwalk syndrome.
3) If this is the policy why drive me and my family all the way there for an exam.
4) I knew that Akershus got me sick and now I was being told that I couldn’t cruise.

I went on a complete rant, I was very mad. Then the nurse tells me that she needs to take my temperature. All the parents and child caregivers out there pay attention. I told the nurse that I did not appreciate her asking to take my temperature after I had been yelling like a mad woman and told her that this would elevate my temperature. She took it and it was 99.4. My pulse was 108. My normal resting pulse is about 68 and that’s at an altitude of 9500 ft.. I told her that I wanted to be seen by the doctor and that she better bring my husband into the room.

My husband came in along with the nurse and the cruise line manager. I was in tears and very unhappy about what was happening to us. The doctor arrived He began speaking to my husband and asked my husband what was wrong with me. My husband and I were both offended that he didn’t speak directly to me and my husband questioned him for not speaking to me directrly. I asked him what the nurse had told him and he told me that the nurse told him that I vomited the night before and that I had a fever. I asked him if she told him about the food poisoning and he said that she didn’t and that it didn’t matter because I had a fever. I told him that a 99.4 degree temperature for females is not an abnormal temperature and also told him that I believed the entire situation may have elevated my temperature. The doctor informed me that a person can not elevate their temperature when they are enraged. A temperature is a constant. He wanted to take my temperature again, I asked him if he would allow me 15 minutes to relax and he told me that he would take my temperature once now and again 15 minutes later. He took my temperature 99.3. and did a small exam listening to my lungs, feeling my abdomen. He then told me that the decision stands. He flatly told my husband that he believed that I had a virus, not food poisoning. Here is my problem with the doctor.

1) Temperature can be elevated when a person becomes angry, any doctor who does not know this is a quack.
2) 99.4 or 99.3 is not necessarily considered an abnormal temperature, particularly in women.
3) What doctor ever makes an absolute diagnosis of a virus. I know that this doctor does not have the ability to do blood work. But he did not ask any questions about my food intake or any of the many questions asked by the claims person. Very arrogant in my opinion.

By the way, the doctor said that this was out of his hands and was due to international maritime regulations. We have since the found that this doesn’t even exist.

So next we had to deal with the cruise line. This took a very long time and a lot of negotiation. Listen if I couldn’t cruise because I was still sick, we had trip insurance. But my complaint here is primarily this. 1) A Disney restaurant gave me food poisoning and now we have been denied passage as a result of it. We are about to incur unexpected costs.

DCL’s first offer was this we could have a cruise credit of what we paid for the cruise $1300.00.

Or

They would put us in a Disney hotel for 3 nights.

Needless to say, this family will not be going on DCL ever again. The Cruise line offer of 3 nights would be at wilderness lodge. The rate that we had for the wilderness lodge was for $109.00 a night. Hardly equivalent to $1300.00 we paid.

So we had to negotiate, we told them that we wanted tickets and the meal plan included. Their counter offer was that they would give us a deluxe hotel and passes. Again the math did not work.

Their last offer was this, a deluxe hotel for three nights, ultimate hopper passes, and a $300.00 room credit for food (they denied knowing about any meal plan). We agreed and thought this was close enough to the equivalent of what we could have planned for the same amount. I wish they had offered it in the beginning instead of making us bargain for it. All of this took two hours. There is no food at the port our son was such a good boy but was hardly sustained on the snacks we packed. We planned to eat once on the ship.

20 minutes later the DCL person gave us a letter for our room, tickets, and the credit we agreed to, except it said that we were staying at the Caribbean Beach Resort. Hold the phone, not a deluxe. I asked her and she informed me that because of the marathon nothing was available at the deluxe resorts. I got out my cell phone and called 407 w disney at a roaming charge of $3.00 a minute. Guess what I found rooms at Grand Floridian, Beach Club, and Animal Kingdom lodge. I told them that I don’t appreciate being lied to and was told that when they called 10 minutes prior nothing was available.

The next 24 hours I continued to have diarrhea but never any other symptoms, my family never got sick and with the exception of the cold weather we managed to have a nice time anyway. Plus I lost 7 lbs.

So here is my advice.

1) If you know that you have symptoms that you can attribute to something other then norwalk virus don’t volunteer that information.
2) The doctor was either a liar with an agenda or was not well trained.
3) Don’t eat at Akershus
4) If you think you have food poisoning from Disney follow-up with it more then I did. I don’t know if you should go to a private hospital or go through Disney claims or what but I did not realize the impact that it was going to have on us.
5) If you get into this type of a situation with the cruise line, and they make you an offer, make sure it’s fair and something you can live with. Don’t trust what they say.
 
So sorry for your troubles. Sounds like a nightmarish time. Glad you were able to salvage some of it.

Again, just proof that there is no way I'll ever use the ship's doctor for seasickness or an upset stomach. I went to the pharmacy the other day and bought a ton of dramamime, Pepto, Immodium and Pepcid. The guy looked at me like I was nuts. But, both DD and DH have allergies and can easily eat something that doesn't agree with them. I want to make sure we are covered.

Hope your future vacations go better!
 
I'm so sorry that your trip was ruined.

A Disney restaurant gave me food poisoning
This is the biggest problem. There was no official diagnosis of this and absolutely no way for the doctor to determine if you had Norwalk or not.

I think its very wrong that you were not given a deluxe hotel. Where did you end up staying?

I would have taken the $1,300 credit.
 
I forgot to write that after confronting the cruise about deluxe resorts being available, we were booked into the beach club and a water view room. Our first time here and wonderful service. I just wish we didn't have to bargain for this. Again, don't settle for something that you do not think is fair.
 

Belu,

I am so sorry to hear about your trip! How frustrating! I think DCL owes you an apology and a FREE cruise, if you would even take one at this point! I can't stop thinking about how terribly they treated you, especially if they thought you were sick! Thanks for the info!:(
 
I read your entire post (in horror) and words cannot express how truly sorry I am to hear about your experience! I commend you on how well organized, collected and calm you are in your post. I would copy it and send a letter to any/all of the higher-ups at Disney.

Unfortunately I agree with QueenTrident in saying that my family and I will not be seeing the ship's doctor for any stomach related problems that should ever arise.
 
Belu........Sorry to hear about your vacation not being what you planned. I was one of the 11/30/02 cancelled magic cruisers. We had similar situations with confusion, rebooking and money back. I swore I would NEVER return to WDW and DCL after our replacement land/sea/land. That was our second sailing with DCL. I wrote a letter to DCL (I'm sure they gave you a card with an address to write to.......do it.) By you telling them that you didn't want the "1300.00 credit" because "you do want to return....ever" they have no reason to cater to you. Here is what we will give you and good bye. On the other hand....if you are dissappointed about your vacation being ruined....and you can't believe how you were treated DCL will do EVERYTHING in their power to get you back again and again. They want no "bad apples".
I had the exact same symptoms last year(2002), the last night back at WDW. I too swore it was food poisoning......but I don't think so. It was Norwak.
On that illness for you sign it does say (if I remember properly) "if you have had "flu like symptoms"". I do believe they gave you the options on that form at the lodge. Refund, stay at the resort, or reschedule another cruise with full credit.

I ended up taking the "offer" DCL sent me in responce to my "letter". Yes, my 11/02 vacation was FAR from enjoyable but with some coaxing from some people here on these boards I DID take another vacation. I DO believe DCL had in our file the problems we had because they seemed to go that "extra mile" for us last November (03). And yes, I have booked yet another 7 nighter. You temp will drop with time....trust me I know how you are feeling now.
 
I feel so very awful for you. I would have demanded a free cruise. Not that it would have help but OMG to think they treated you this way.

My mom and I are going on a 4-night cruise in September. Makes me wonder if we should try a different cruise line. My mom has only been on a boat once in her entire life and she was sick before we even left port.

Makes me wonder what they do to people who get motion sickness before you leave port.
 
Wow That really sucks -Excuse my french.LOLSo SOrry for your experience.I hope you enjoyed the rest of the trip.
I had this happen to me at DL -I got sick from the Rainforest Food. They credited me my food only because after eating half the sandwhich you could see the chicken was obviously not cooked.About 2 hours after eating I got deathly ill while waiting for the Tiki Brids.My dh summoned first aid as I could not stand up and couldn't stop vomitting.The nurse in DL told me my birth control pills were making me sick not the food.
BTW I was so sick that my blood sugar was dropping and I was blacking out. My heartrate was also 140 resting from excessive vomitting.
My temp was 99.5 which is quite regular for me. I have never had a 98.6 temp in my life. The nurse in DL started to say it was viral but when I told her I always have that temp she agreed that it wasn't really a fever.
I agree you deserve to be better compensated than time at WDW.
 
I am sorry this happened to you as well. I had a similar situation. I thought I had food poisoning - very similar to your circumstance and was ready to blame the restaurant I ate at. (not at Disney) ---and then I spoke to my mom the next day and she said that I had eight relatives with the same thing - and we didn't eat together but were together. Then I knew I had Norwalk.

Unfortunately there is no immediate diagnosis for Norwalk or food poisoning - so I think that DCL has to be cautious. Unfortunately, this could ruin some guest's vacations.

Hope you are feeling better.
 
Am I the only one who thinks that Disney's response was reasonable? I guess the first thing to do before getting into a debate is to read the cruise contract that everyone has to sign. It's that long boring part at the end of your documentation. I actually read it not too long ago (ok, so I was really bored). The gist of it is that they have the right to refuse passage for a number of reasons, one of which is illness.

I know that you are convinced it was food poisoning, but when you are talking about the well being of 2400 passengers, I think the guidelines must be a little more strict.

Imagine if you were a passenger who ended up getting ill, along with hundreds of other passengers only to have Disney end the cruise early (this has happened). Then imagine that Disney knew the person who brought the illness on board was vomiting hours before boarding, and let her board anyway because she was sure it wasn't contagious. I think Disney owes it to the 2399 other passengers to do its best to prevent the possibility of a viral outbreak.

The offer of $1300 in credit was basically an offer to cruise on the same ship at another time. That sounds reasonable to me. The fact that you had to bargain to get an alternative may not be a pleasant experience, but a calmer reaction to the initial news may have gotten you better results.

If it happened to me, I'm sure I'd be upset too, but if you look at the big picture, you have to understand why it was done.
 
Originally posted by sixbitslocum
Am I the only one who thinks that Disney's response was reasonable?

No you're not the only one.

Giving a $1,300 refund to someone who had trip insurance is extremely generous. The confusion with the hotels is still confusing.

I don't remember the exact figure, but evidently cruise ships have to report illnesses on their ships when they reach a certain percentage of ill passengers. Evidently the percentage is the lowest of any of the service industries.

Then the press gets a hold of these things and goes nuts with it.

Then people want to back out of cruises.

The industry has to be unbelivably careful and unfortunately, it's very difficult to tell the difference between Norwalk and food poisoning. And belu, I am not speaking of you, but people do lie in order to still take their cruise.

I don't feel DCL had much choice and were pretty generous considering.

My normal temp. is 97º. A 99.4º temp. for me would definitely indicate an illness, but you would say I was within normal range. Because of this, I would think they would need to stick with 98.6º as the temp. a cruise line needs to use as normal.

Again, I'm sorry that your trip turned to such a nightmare and I hope you are feeling better.
 
I want to echo what a few other posters have stated here. Disney had no way of knowing for sure if you had Norwalk but then again - neither did you. For safety's sake I believe Disney did the right thing by denying you access to the boat simply because without a blood test there was no 100% way to know for sure. You had been on a plane within the last 12-24 hours, it was probably a very good chance that it WAS Norwalk. The symptoms are the same as for food poisoning so how do you know for sure? As for the rest of their offer, everyone has their own definition of fair. I would have wanted my money refunded, not a cruise credit.
 
I completely agree with six and crb. I think that Disney was very reasonable and they certainly did not have to give you anything at all in exchange for refunding your cruise. If you read through all of the fine print in the contract you will see that Disney actually went out of their way for you and your family. I understand that it is disappointing for you and your family not to go on the cruise, however you have to think about the well-being of the other passengers as well as your own well-being. What if you had been out at sea with your condition and it became much worse. Would you want to be sick on land or sick at sea or possibly worse sick in the Bahammas? I am not trying to be mean to what happened with you and your family. I can understand your disappointment in not being able to cruise, however I think that it is unfair for you to libel Disney with your posting. In fairness to Disney, there was the Walt Disney World Marathon this past weekend. I know since I have run it three times that the hotels are almost always all full and they are usually required to book at least three nights minimum for their stay. We all know that people cancel hotels at any given moment. As it turns out when you called, a cancellation might have been made. I hope that you and your family will take a Disney Cruise again and stay loyal to Walt Disney. Often times people are so quick to criticize and pass judgement in a company or think that they are not getting good service and are trying to take advantage of a situation. I think that this was not completely the case with you, however I feel that Disney went above and beyond in doing their best for you given the unfortunate circumstances. Think about this way, why would Disney or any company want to mistreat their customer. The fact is that they would not and that they did their best in this situation for you. Take Care!
 
I can see this from both sides....I'd hate to have my vacation ruined because of someone else who was sick....but, if I really, truly knew that it wasn't contagious, I'd be mad, too.
My temp is always 99.8...that's normal for me, and I've never had a doctor or a nurse question it.
I also have ulcerative colitis, and try to never be without my meds, but sometimes I forget. I know now not to go to the ship's doctor for help with it!! ;)
I wouldn't hold it against DCL, though. I'm sure every cruise line would be the same, and maybe not as accomodating. No one else has a WDW to send you to!
I can't think of anything that would make me not want to cruise Disney!!
 
I can see Disney's point of view. I think if there is any chance that you had a virus they are not going to let you on the ship. Something which I am glad if I am also going to be a paying customer on that ship.

As you said, it is better not to mention to Disney if you have been sick at all. That is if you want to go on the cruise.

I have to give you an A plus in negotiation skills. I actually think Disneys offer of an equal cruise was fair. But my hat is off to you to get all you did out of them. I think they were more than fair to give you all that they did. But of course it was only because you were so good and skillful at negotiating with them.

I have eaten at the Akershus resturant many times. Its a great place and highly rated. Sorry you had a bad experience there.
 
Again I did not want to start a debate about this being fair or not. I simply wanted to share my experiance so that others are aware of what happened. I'm sure that most of the people who sailed on the 8th had a wonderful trip with no complaints. I would also guess that for the number of people served food at Disney they probably have below average occurrances of food poisoning incidents.

I do need to say this. I am a stranger to all that are reading this, you can't know for sure that I actually had food poisoning or not. Because I failed to seek a diagnosis I will not know for sure either. I admit that I don't know. At the end of my post I listed my advice. Some may think that Disney did not do enough, others think they did too little. My hope is that if you read this post you will remember this if you get sick at Disney or anywhere else. Remember that just because your feeling better or your not the kind of person looking for an easy lawsuit, you should consider what the full impact of your illness is and make decisions based on that. If I could go back in time I would have called an ambulance that night when I was sick. There would be no question then. Another reason for my post is to tell you about my experiance with the ship doctor and nurse. And lastly, I feel that DCL employees were less than empathetic and that they lied to us. Also, we were never offered a refund. And we did not receive any contract untill at the hotel on the 8th. In the end we got what we felt was fair. We finished our vacation and had some fun despite the lingering illness and weather. I am not seeking any additional compensation from DCL . I'm also not telling people that they should not cruise DCL. I just wanted to tell my story.
 
I know that it would be horrible to be looking so forward to cruising and then not be allowed, but I think that Disney did the right thing and was more than fair. The thing that bothers me is that we are sending the message to lie when asked if you've been sick so that you won't have a problem. Disney is doing this for all of our sakes. I don't think anyone, including a doctor, can diagnose themselves with food poisoning rather than a virus. It's wishful thinking.
 
belu,

I really am sorry that you got sick and that your trip was ruined, but like you have admitted you really had no way of being able to tell if you had a norwalk-like virus or not. You had all of the symptoms and since the blood test takes several days to come back, there is no way for DCL to definitively tell what was causing you to have those awful symptoms. You could have just as easily touched something that someone else who did not wash their hands after going to the bathroom touched and picked up a virus. I always come home from Disney with some kind of a cold, no matter how diligent I am about hand washing, because you just can't get around touching things that a million other people have touched on attractions.

I guess what I am saying is that DCL did not ruin your vacation or cause you to have a horrible experience, but your illness (whatever caused it) did. I'm sorry if you didn't feel that you were being unfairly treated but IMO it was your shock that you would not be allowed to cruise that made you so upset and not anything that DCL did.

My guess is that they are not really set up at the port to book people into land only package vacations as I'm guessing this doesn't happen very often, so I'd cut them a little slack about the hotel reservations, especially given the fact that you "negotiated" something that was apparently nonstandard. I have no doubt that if you had taken the cruise credit things would have gone quite a bit more smoothly as DCL does seem to be MORE than fair about working with passengers who cannot cruise and for whatever reason cancel within the 60 day window where DCL can just as easily give them nothing and be 100% within their rights. This is one of the scenarios for which people purchase travel insurance, if you become ill and cannot travel.

I hope you can understand what the people who disagree with you are saying. I think pretty much EVERYONE can sympathize with your really crappy situation. I feel horrible that you had to get so sick and missed out on your cruise. I guess I just see a big difference between DCL being responsible for your bad time and having a bad time because you got sick. DCL did not make you sick, nor did they suddenly invent a new policy to apply just to you. Yes, it is WAY sucky when it happens to you but it's not DCL's fault.

Lisa
 

GET UP TO A $1000 SHIPBOARD CREDIT AND AN EXCLUSIVE GIFT!

If you make your Disney Cruise Line reservation with Dreams Unlimited Travel you’ll receive these incredible shipboard credits to spend on your cruise!

























DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top