One more question, and you can PM your responses if that's more comfortable. Are your homeschoolers going on to college?
DS15 has no interest in college, none at all. I think it's, in part, because he had such a difficult time in school. I'm not comfortable going into it all on a public forum but the culmination of everything is what led us to homeschool him. It just wasn't a positive situation for him.
College always comes up with other homeschool parents and I end up feeling like a leper. It's never actually been said straight out but the intimation is a question of why am I homeschooling if my child isn't going on to college.
Am I that much of an odd duck?

I mean I already feel like an odd duck for homeschooling but I'm starting to feel even more odd for not grooming my son for college.
I've made my opinions on college being the end-all clear, so I won't jump on the entire soapbox again.

But....I get SO tired of people who think the only way to judge the success of their homeschooler is by their college/career choice. REALLY irritates me and is one of the few things that makes me want to smack someone.
Let me preface our experience so far with telling you that I just got my Master's last year. My dad is a professor in a Master's program. I used to be an English teacher. We VALUE education and even higher education in my family.
My oldest went to PS. She was HSed for a few years, but wound up back in (long story). She went to college for one year on a full scholarship and flunked out. She is 25yo and still has no degree nor any drive to get one. She is gainfully employed FT at WDW and seems to be content with that.
My 22yo was in PS for about 3 years, then pulled to HS. She returned to PS for 2 years, but came back to HS. My parents tried to push her back to PS, but she finally asked if she could just take the GED and "get it over with". She did. She went to community college for a semester to qualify for the Disney College Program which she did and parlayed that into a job there. BTW, she's worked since she was 15yo. She has worked 2 jobs for a few years now and is very happy. She recently announced that she is going back to school this summer. I don't personally think she's cut out for it, but I'm happy to see that she has the gumption to try. She is VERY smart and the professors will annoy her. It's just the way she is.
3rd DD is 15 next week and has absolutely no desire to go to college. She has a strong interest in photography, which I encourage as much as possible (she got an amazing camera for Christmas). She is more interested in gaining work-related skills so we are especially concerned with making sure that math makes sense in a real-world environment. She sees the diversity of jobs available at WDW and is looking to experiment around there and find her niche.
Youngest is 12 and already has photos of the CIA in New York in her daily binder. She has calculated how much she needs to save in the next 6 years, what her GPA needs to be, and what score she needs on the SAT to qualify for scholarships. She's already started asking me for SAT study guides.

She has a chef coat/pants and has already started a nice collection of kitchen accouterments which she uses on a regular basis. She makes a lovely alfredo sauce!
Not every kid is cut out for college. I certainly had no interest and was pressured into it. I wound up dropping out to get married (which felt like my ONLY escape at the time and turned out to be a horrible, life-altering in too many ways mistake). I had to return to college later in life to support a family alone and was much more motivated to do well. In my opinion, the time each person is ready, if they ever are, is individual and depends on many factors. In today's college world, there is no such thing as a "non-traditional student" anymore (like I was). Help children find their passions and pursue them. Some kids actually LIKE the idea of mixing ice cream at Cold Stone and watching the kids faces light up at the first taste of the concoction. We can't all be rocket scientists.
And, one more thing...look at the number of people wandering around unemployment offices with degrees right now. It really is not the end-all.