Talk to Mike first indeed!
You have to eat at Tide me Over or Signals at least once. Get a burger with Onion rings or the sweet potato fries. If Joyce is cooking, consider yourself lucky! She is the best.
We liked One Hot Momma's, Pazzo (across the highway from the resort, under the water tower, the walk over is fabulous), and Signe's.
The best meal we had during our last visit was the one we cooked on the grill next to Big Murgee's Den. We got some very nice steaks from the Fresh Market just down the highway, and grilled them.
You can also come over to Savannah and get a fine meal on River St. If you come over for lunch, try to get into Mrs Wilkes. Paula Deen's place has gone downhill since she quit running the place.
If you want pizza here, go to Vinnie-Van-Go Go's. Be aware that they do not take credit. Cash ONLY!