Hudson's on the Docks!! I've tried Scott's twice and was disappointed both times. It was
okay food, and sitting outside with live music is nice - but I did not think it was not anywhere close to "great" fresh seafood. Crazy Crab was much better - but they do use MSG - an ingredient I am deathly allergic to - in their fried fish

Still, it's got a wonderful atmosphere (the one in Harbourtown is next to a lighthouse). DH said the fried fish was very tasty and my steamed shrimp was yummy.
But - Hudson's on the Docks was FABULOUS seafood. I'm a Florida native, so I love, love, love good, fresh, local seafood. Hudson's had delicious oysters and crab cakes - and DH got the blackened catch of the day and it was delicious.