Just a recommendation... check the internet for "most popular baby names". Make sure to check for your state. When we were naming DS8, we were going to use the name "Alexander" until we realized that every baby boy we knew was named "Alexander" so we named him "Ethan" instead. We then moved to a different state where "Ethan" was one of the most popular names for boys. Thankfully, we moved to yet a third state and "Ethan" is the only one of his kind at his school... though, the names "Olivia", "Timothy", and "Abigail" are super popular.
I like the name Wyatt for a first name too if you can't find another name you like better.
While I was reading your post, I was thinking Wyatt the entire time! I couldn't belive it when I saw that you are thinking of this for a middle name! Great minds think alike! I love the name Wyatt. Ok now I will try to come up with some first names for you.
Oh I almost forgot, congratulations on your soon-to-be-new-baby!
If you are thinking you like more old-fashioned names, I just got out the family tree my grandfather compiled that goes back to 1545. Some of the names:
Nicholas
Roger
Ezekiel
Franklin
Ward
Wallace
Samuel
Edward
Eli
Matthew
(as well as John, William, Richard, Thomas, Henry and George)
There's also a set of twin girls, born in 1855, named Hannah and Harriet. I thought that was kind of cute!