You didn't say whether or not you liked Lobster (I have only met one person in my liife who didn't, lol)
Appetizers You might like:
Creamy Lobster Soup - chervil, brandy $7.00
Corn Chowder - fresh corn and bacon $6.00
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail - chilled shrimp, spicy cocktail sauce $10.00
Blue Crab Cake - served on fresh corn salsa with sour cream and chive sauce $10.00
Beef Skewers - tenderloin marinated in a sweet and rich glaze, accompanied by a celery root puree $10.00
Caesar Salad - $6; add fried rock shrimp or a grilled chicken breast for an additional $6.00
Mixed Greens - blue cheese dressing or Key Lime herb vinaigrette $6.00
Entrees You might like:
Grilled Chicken Breast - served with wild mushroom risotto with truffle butter $21.50 (ask for a different side, WDW restaurants are very accomodating)
Grilled Shrimp - served over linguine pasta tossed with lobster sauce and Brussels sprouts $27.50 (If you like lobster)
Grilled Filet Mignon - served with potatoes Au Gratin, and beef demi-glace $30.50
Last time I ate at Coral Reef, I made my meal out of appetizers. I usually can't eat entree size portions. I have also been offered the option of making an appetizer an entree sized portion at WDW restaurants before. That might be a possibility for you as well.