Help Me narrow it down?

[staticgirl50]

Ok we are going from 1/13-1/20
We are doing the DDP, these are our choices so far but there are to many! Help me choose which ones or if something really blows let me know! We have a 4 year lil princess to think of as well!

Tusker House Dinner ( Never been)
50's Prime Time Dinner (Been here Before)
Play N Dine Hollywood and Vine Lunch ( Never Been)
Mamma MelroseDinner Fantasmic pkg. (Never Been)
Sci Fi Dinner (Never Been)
Liberty Tree Tavern Dinner ( Been BUT there was still characters) LOVED this
Crystal Palace Dinner (Been Here)
California Grill Dinner ( Never Been)
Chef Mickeys ( Been here its a must) DD loves it!
Whispering Canyon Dinner (never Been)

Thanks so much!!!!

 

[ChefaStepha]

Ok, I think you're a little behind in the times! The Concourse Steakhouse has closed. It was a delish place, and I miss it ever so much! As you know, LTT has no characters. I thought the food at the Hollywood & Vine was horrific, and the service and food has gone downhill at the Crystal Palace.

Chef Mickey's is great, I've never been to Whispering Canyon or Mama Melrose but I've heard great things as well about Tusker House and 50's Prime Time.

Have a great trip!

 

[ChefaStepha]

Also, maybe you could use 2 credits and take your little girl to Cinderella's Royal Table in the castle after you get her hair done at the Bibbidi Bobbidi Boutique. Just a suggestion... .

 

[ciera321]

I miss Concourse, too! The only one on your list that I would not return is Hollywood and Vine, just not good at all (IMO), but the rest look great.

 

[chloelovesdisney]

Ok we are going from 1/13-1/20
We are doing the DDP, these are our choices so far but there are to many! Help me choose which ones or if something really blows let me know! We have a 4 year lil princess to think of as well!

Tusker House Dinner ( Never been)
50's Prime Time Dinner (Been here Before)
Play N Dine Hollywood and Vine Lunch ( Never Been)
Mamma MelroseDinner Fantasmic pkg. (Never Been)
Sci Fi Dinner (Never Been)
Liberty Tree Tavern Dinner ( Been but there was still characters) LOVED this
Crystal Palace Dinner (Been Here)
California Grill Dinner ( Never Been)
Chef Mickeys ( Been here its a must) DD loves it!
Concourse Steakhouse Dinner (Never Been)
Whispering Canyon Dinner (never Been)

Thanks so much!!!!

I'd keep Sci Fi but maybe for lunch, Crystal Palace, California Grill, Chef Mickey's, Whispering Canyon. I like Liberty Tree Tavern but not sure what will be going on there in January. Mama Melrose I don't like at all but my family had a miserable experience there, it's the one restaurant in Disney I'll never return to. I haven't been to Tusker House since they changed to TS but have heard their breakfast is great, haven't heard about their dinner.

 

[staticgirl50]

Also, maybe you could use 2 credits and take your little girl to Cinderella's Royal Table in the castle after you get her hair done at the Bibbidi Bobbidi Boutique. Just a suggestion... .

Did this last year- She really has no desire to do it again, she was actually-------BORED!

 

[staticgirl50]

Ok deleted Concourse--Blushing--- Oopsie
Apparently Hollywood and Vine stinks so thats out...Maybe Mamma's is out, anywhere better to go?

 

[Lollipop's Mom]

Tusker House Dinner ( Never been) - had brekkie here and LOVED it. Not sure about dinner, but if it was as good as brekkie - Id do it.
50's Prime Time Dinner (Been here Before) - Most horrible food I have ever had in my life
Play N Dine Hollywood and Vine Lunch ( Never Been) -if your little one loves those characters Id do it
Mamma MelroseDinner Fantasmic pkg. (Never Been) - never been
Sci Fi Dinner (Never Been) LOVE this place! Some hate it, we LOVED it
Liberty Tree Tavern Dinner ( Been BUT there was still characters) LOVED this - when we went in January it had gone way down hill - food was terrible
Crystal Palace Dinner (Been Here) - in january we hated the food here
California Grill Dinner ( Never Been) - never been
Chef Mickeys ( Been here its a must) DD loves it! - one of our faves!
Whispering Canyon Dinner (never Been) - never been and always wanted to

 

[ChefaStepha]

Did this last year- She really has no desire to do it again, she was actually-------BORED!

Bored! That's just CRAZY!

 

[cerilene]

I guess I'm the only one, but we love the Play and Dine for lunch. They have a larger selection of food than most of the character buffets and the characters are great. It is very loud with all of the singing and dancing that they do, but the little ones in our group love it. We went in April and they had the regular buffet items plus about 6 or 7 pasta dishes. Have thought it was yummy both times we went.
Whispering Canyon Cafe is very good and we love 50's Prime Time. We thought the food at Sci-fi was lacking and the service wasn't very good either, the atmosphere was really cool though. The Biergarten in Germany is fun and the food is good, especially the desserts, if you want to try something a bit different. Good luck!

 

[staticgirl50]

Bored! That's just CRAZY!

I know- but she was like yeah its a castle, who cares...Now put her in the Dinosaur part of AK- shes all for it! Yet she is still super girly, loves jewelry and looking pretty. I think the Castle was just to busy for her to soak it all in!

 

[Tink030]

Did this last year- She really has no desire to do it again, she was actually-------BORED!

Maybe she was too young to enjoy it
We are taking our two younger girls to get their hair done and to crt for the 3rd
time and they can't get enough.
The food there isn't the best, but it is something I will do until they are too old to not want to.

 

[bkfree]

We love Crystal Palace and my kids and hubby insist on it every trip.

Our favorite place for Cinderella is not CRT but Dinner with Cinderella and Prince Charming and others at 1900 Park Fare at the Grand Floridian. Great food and great character interaction.
It wins hands down over the castle in our family.

LTT- Frozen Stouffers meal to us-never again.

Sci Fi - great one of a kind atmosphere and good enough food- more of a lunch than dinner place for us.

I noticed that you did not have any places at World Showcase, which I think have some of the best eating at WDW. Check out the menus at those and add one, I could not imagine a trip without one or two dinners at WS.

 

[CinderellyCinderelly]

My vote is for mama melrose, and stay away from wcc!

 

[ROEDISNEY]

Ok we are going from 1/13-1/20
We are doing the DDP, these are our choices so far but there are to many! Help me choose which ones or if something really blows let me know! We have a 4 year lil princess to think of as well!

Tusker House Dinner ( Never been)
50's Prime Time Dinner (Been here Before)
Play N Dine Hollywood and Vine Lunch ( Never Been)
Mamma MelroseDinner Fantasmic pkg. (Never Been)
Sci Fi Dinner (Never Been)
Liberty Tree Tavern Dinner ( Been BUT there was still characters) LOVED this
Crystal Palace Dinner (Been Here)
California Grill Dinner ( Never Been)
Chef Mickeys ( Been here its a must) DD loves it!
Whispering Canyon Dinner (never Been)

Thanks so much!!!!

Tusker House Dinner Good
50's Prime Time Dinner Good
Play N Dine Hollywood and Vine Lunch
I heard not so good never been there
Mamma MelroseDinner Fantasmic pkg.
Good wouldn't book a F.pkg
Sci Fi Dinner Good
Liberty Tree Tavern Dinner ( Been BUT there was still characters) LOVED this
Good
Crystal Palace Dinner Good
California Grill Dinner Good
Chef Mickeys ( Been here its a must) DD loves it! Good
Whispering Canyon Dinner (never Been) Good