I like both dresses. I tried on #2 and didn't like it on me, it looks very nice on you... but I like #1 better! I saw that one at David's when I went to buy a new sash and just love it. I had to leave before attempting to try it on since I am already a 2 dress bride! I think #1 looks amazing on you... it has the pickup skirt which I think is done in a unique way. I also love the lace at the bottom. Good luck with your decision!