Has anyone successfully helped your child lose weight?

Mom21

DIS Veteran
Joined
Feb 16, 2004
Messages
1,917
We have struggled with my dd's weight for years. I am at a loss as to what to do next. She has always been very active. She was involved in gymnastics for years, often practicing 9-12 hours a week at the end before she stopped. She doesn't watch much tv. She prefers to play. She has at various times been involved in dance, horseback riding, PE classes (when we homeschooled), baton/hip-hop, swim team, and is now in cheer. So not a sedentary child. She often uses her scooter and roller blades. Hours a week are spent perfecting dance moves. She also has Dance Dance Revolution she likes. Also due to nutritionist suggestion she has to do 15 minutes a day on treadmill, but she hates it, and I don't want to cause her to hate exercise and think of it as a punishment.

We rarely (actually almost never) eat fried food. She doesn't like fast food. She says McD's gives her a tummy ache. If we eat out fast food it is Subway, but that is maybe once a month. She mainly drinks water. rarely a soda, and if she does, it is sugar free. Here is a typical day of food. Her favorite cereal is South Beach Diet. I measure her portion so 3/4 cup for 110 calories. She has 1/2 cup 1% milk for 55 calories (but she doesn't finish itso maybe gets only half the calories). I also give her vitamin and calcium supplements for 30 calories total. I like her to have oatmeal, but I only buy the reduced sugar one. She maybe eats this once a week as she prefers cereal.

Lunch varies. Sometimes she buys at school, but never gets anything but the main course or a salad. Mostly she packs. She may pack a PB&J which is made on 100% whole wheat NO SUGAR ADDED bread with natural pb (only peanuts, no extras), and sugar free jelly. Chips are baked. Then a fruit. Her newest favorite is the South Beach Diet wraps. She loves these things for 210-240 calories. I add in a fruit. Only water when I pack. Sometimes at school she has the juice or a milk.

Snacks. She is allowed 1 snack when she gets home. I took her to a nutritionist that suggest the 100 calorie snacks from Ritz so I use these a lot. Also she is allowed one ice cream a day. Depending on what she has eaten this can be the Guilt Free ice cream pops. She loves these. They are ice cream covered in chocolate for 100 calories.

Dinner. We rarely fry or eat red meat. Most dinners are chicken, fish, or occasionally pork. I will have a protein, add some rice or potato (I try to use sweet potatoes), and something green (broccoli, salad, snap peas, etc). I will admit her portions are large, but we have reduced them significantly in the last year.

I have had it with her dr getting on my case every year. Yes sir. I know she needs to lose weight. I took her to a nutritionist, but for $150 per hour you would think I would get more input. She wanted dd to come back every 6 weeks. Sorry way too much money for her to tell me we eat pretty good. It would be so easy if we ate poorly, but it seems no matter what i do we can't get her weight under control. Yes, she does occasionally have treats and candy and extras, but I try to take that into account when I allow her the snacks or extras at meals. For example, tonight a friend gave her a Capri Sun (UGH) and a gummy treat. I told her she could have it but then no snack. That was her snack so don't expect to come home and have ice cream.

So has anyone successfully helped a child lose weight? This is so frustrating to try and do the right thing, and feel as if that is all I focus on and still have the dr upset every year at her physical. I certainly don't want to cause an eating disorder, but this isn't getting any better.
 
How old is your daughter and how overweight is she?

I had a chubby 10-year-old who has turned into a skinny 14-year-old. Sometime it is just pre-puberty where they pack on the pounds, before the growth spurt.

It sounds like you ARE doing everything right. Has she been tested for any metabolic problems?
 
I don't know if this will help, my ds is 13 and currently weight is doing OK, but when he was 10,11 and 12 he played football and always had to lose weight or not play,pop warner rules. I can tell you how to lose weight but it is not a long term plan, under dr's watch we did this for 1 month and my ds lost 10-15 pounds each year. then we could maintain. He ate a slim fast bar for breakfast and lunch. He could have one piece of fruit in the morning, one in the afternoon and for dinner he ate lean meat grilled or baked with veggies(not corn) with spray margarine if he wanted. He could have as much lettuce and cucumbers plain as he wanted. He also drank 3 glasses of skim milk a day.
He too was very active. He didn't cheat at all because he wanted to play football more than anything.

It is hard to deprive your child of anything, but recently I have taken all snacks out of my house, as everyone could use to eat a bit healthier. Ice Cream is something we have maybe once a month, no cookies no candy. The kids have rediscovered fruit and love it. I didn't do this as a punishment but more for health reasons(we have had a few things going on lately). The kids are doing great, but they also tell me when they really really need something sweet.

Have you had your dd's thyroid checked. That too can slow metabolism and lead to weight gain.

Good Luck, its not easy, just tell her you love her no matter what and your there to help her with whatever she will ever need.
 
I helped my 13 year old DS lose 20 lbs in 6 weeks this summer so he could make weight to play football. You didnt say how old your child is but she sounds like my son. Very active and a very poor matabolism.The only thing that has ever worked for my DS is LOW CARB. He never starved,he ate very healthy, and absolutely no SUGAR. No rice No potatos low carb bread that I buy from Great Harvest bakery He lived on low carb bars for lunch. salads meat eggs and very little fruit. In order to lose weight your body will burn the carbs you consumme first. So if you are eating carbs when you exercise your body burns them first so if you dont eat carbs or very little your body will burn fat and then you will lose weight. I hope this helps out a little. I know from experience how frustrating it is to help your children become healthy eaters and not see results. Good Luck to you Mimimom
 

To the OP--WOW! You are an amazing mother :grouphug:
 
A friend of mine had her daughter join weight watchers. I think it requires OK from the pediatrician and everything is adjusted to account for the fact that kids need to grow.

And like adult dieters--it could be she is not consuming enough calories and is deficit in some important nutrition that she needs.

So I would suggest contacting WW to see if they can help and it is at a fraction of a cost of the nutritionist.

I have seen a difference in the girl I am speaking about. While she is growing taller--you can really tell that she does have less body fat. Still chubby--but getting closer to healthy size.

I've been following my calories and pre-planning my menus for the day and keeping my fat at 25% or less total for the day and my protein 25% or higher. As long as the numbers add up--then I can mix and match with that. So you may find out what the nutritional needs are for kids--then plan variety in her menus so that it accomplishes that.
 
Mom21 said:
We have struggled with my dd's weight for years. I am at a loss as to what to do next. She has always been very active. She was involved in gymnastics for years, often practicing 9-12 hours a week at the end before she stopped. She doesn't watch much tv. She prefers to play. She has at various times been involved in dance, horseback riding, PE classes (when we homeschooled), baton/hip-hop, swim team, and is now in cheer. So not a sedentary child. She often uses her scooter and roller blades. Hours a week are spent perfecting dance moves. She also has Dance Dance Revolution she likes. Also due to nutritionist suggestion she has to do 15 minutes a day on treadmill, but she hates it, and I don't want to cause her to hate exercise and think of it as a punishment.

We rarely (actually almost never) eat fried food. She doesn't like fast food. She says McD's gives her a tummy ache. If we eat out fast food it is Subway, but that is maybe once a month. She mainly drinks water. rarely a soda, and if she does, it is sugar free. Here is a typical day of food. Her favorite cereal is South Beach Diet. I measure her portion so 3/4 cup for 110 calories. She has 1/2 cup 1% milk for 55 calories (but she doesn't finish itso maybe gets only half the calories). I also give her vitamin and calcium supplements for 30 calories total. I like her to have oatmeal, but I only buy the reduced sugar one. She maybe eats this once a week as she prefers cereal.

Lunch varies. Sometimes she buys at school, but never gets anything but the main course or a salad. Mostly she packs. She may pack a PB&J which is made on 100% whole wheat NO SUGAR ADDED bread with natural pb (only peanuts, no extras), and sugar free jelly. Chips are baked. Then a fruit. Her newest favorite is the South Beach Diet wraps. She loves these things for 210-240 calories. I add in a fruit. Only water when I pack. Sometimes at school she has the juice or a milk.

Snacks. She is allowed 1 snack when she gets home. I took her to a nutritionist that suggest the 100 calorie snacks from Ritz so I use these a lot. Also she is allowed one ice cream a day. Depending on what she has eaten this can be the Guilt Free ice cream pops. She loves these. They are ice cream covered in chocolate for 100 calories.

Dinner. We rarely fry or eat red meat. Most dinners are chicken, fish, or occasionally pork. I will have a protein, add some rice or potato (I try to use sweet potatoes), and something green (broccoli, salad, snap peas, etc). I will admit her portions are large, but we have reduced them significantly in the last year.

I have had it with her dr getting on my case every year. Yes sir. I know she needs to lose weight. I took her to a nutritionist, but for $150 per hour you would think I would get more input. She wanted dd to come back every 6 weeks. Sorry way too much money for her to tell me we eat pretty good. It would be so easy if we ate poorly, but it seems no matter what i do we can't get her weight under control. Yes, she does occasionally have treats and candy and extras, but I try to take that into account when I allow her the snacks or extras at meals. For example, tonight a friend gave her a Capri Sun (UGH) and a gummy treat. I told her she could have it but then no snack. That was her snack so don't expect to come home and have ice cream.

So has anyone successfully helped a child lose weight? This is so frustrating to try and do the right thing, and feel as if that is all I focus on and still have the dr upset every year at her physical. I certainly don't want to cause an eating disorder, but this isn't getting any better.


I don't have any advice for you just :grouphug: and It looks to me like you are on the right track.She is an active girl and eats sensibly.I wouldn't want to focus too much on it like you said I'd be afraid of eating disorders.You didn't mention her age or weight range but I'm guessing maybe she is getting ready for a growth spurt?Society is so tough on kids especially girls.I have a 5 yr old that already talks about "losing her belly"Her big sister and brother are thin and she still has "baby fat"..
 
Sounds like you and your DD are doing everything right. I, too, wouldn't want to place a lot of focus on this. Each person's perfect body size is individualized. I hope that DD's doctor wasn't simply looking at percentages on a chart and is considering how your DD has ranked from birth on. My DD practically falls off the low end of the chart, but her pediatrician always notes that she was "born tiny." I read somewhere recently that Shaquille O'Neal is considered morbidly obese based on his BMI. Thought that was an interesting one.

I second the posters questioning if you've had DD's thyroid checked. This was my first thought.

Sounds like you're doing a fabulous job in supporting a healthy lifestyle for your family. Kudos to you! :)
 
She may actually be consuming too much sugar (an ice cream a day and her overall eating plan seems to include too many refined foods), may need to drink more water, may need more protein (I cannot say less carbs because kids need their carbs for energy), and increase the produce.

Watching calories is important, but so is the quality of food and amount of sugar (hidden sugars that accumulate quickly throughout the day) because sugar affects insulin levels.

Has her nutritionist spoken to you about the glycemic index? Insulin can make you fat/gain weight. How about her BMI?
 
Thank you everyone for the kind replies. I was so scared to post this thinking I would get flamed. My dd will be 9 in March. She is about 20 pounds overweight (I say 10-15) according to both the dr and the nutritionist. She is 53" and 88#. This isn't a puberty thing, as she has been consistently overweight for about 4-5 years. She does have very large muscles from years of gymnastics training. Her legs and rear will never be small and that is ok---think JLo....LOL. Her belly is really an issue. I also noticed in her class picture she got this week how large her face looks in comparison to others. I wanted to believe it wasn't that big of a deal, but the picture made me realize she is much larger than others her age. My problem is how much do I try and work on it with her without causing an eating disorder later. I really do not want that to happen but we need to get a handle on it before it gets too far out of control. I can see that happening. As you can see, I try to control it now and she is still overweight. Imagine if I did nothing.

Thanks again for any info and for being so kind about it. I do so love my baby girl and don't want her to suffer later in life because of my mistakes now.
 
I also wanted to make the s uggestion to check out her thyroid levels--i had thyroid problems since i was 8 years old..even now, at 21, my weight will fluctuate alot--doesnt matter what i eat...if my levels are too low, i gain weight, if my levels are too high-i lose weight...
just another thing to consider!
 
Mom21 said:
She is 53" and 88#.
That doesn't sound heavy at all! My DD is 13, she's about 5'6" and weighs 130 pounds....she's not the least bit fat, actually on the thin side of average. I can't imagine 3 inches makes that much of a difference!
 
cruisnfamily said:
That doesn't sound heavy at all! My DD is 13, she's about 5'6" and weighs 130 pounds....she's not the least bit fat, actually on the thin side of average. I can't imagine 3 inches makes that much of a difference!

I think that she possibly means 53 inches?
 
Just a question about your DD's pediatrician - what is he doing to try to help the situation - other than criticize your efforts?

Hugs to both of you.
 
My DD went through being overweight from age 8 until puberty at 12. Then she lost 30 or more pounds. She's in 10th grade now and is regularly in about a size 9. I'm fine with that...and no one calls her "fat".

I'm overweight, and I was throughout childhood. I think if my mom had laid off of me it wouldn't have been that big of an issue. Somehow, I learned that I could comfort myself with food.

There's probably a good chance that your daughter is sneaking food when you aren't around...and it's probably the food you're trying to keep from her to help her lose weight. Teach her moderation in those foods she loves, and promise that she'll get more when she really wants it.

Most of all, assure her that you'll always love her and that her weight is not a condition of your love. It may seem apparent to you, but it might not be to her.

Good luck to you. :grouphug:
 
First, I think you're doing a great job. I don't work as a nutritionist, but I do have a degree in it. I studied nutrition because of the food issues I developed as a teen. I completely understand your not wanting to create a eating disorder or body image problem, but this is a health issue. The goal is to improve her eating now to avoid heart problems and diabetes. The fortunate side effect of changing her diet will be weight loss.

On her diet, the only things that stood out are the sugar treats and portion control, especially at dinner. Occasional treats are OK and you're doing the exact right thing by reducing her other meals to compensate. Ice cream and snack cracker/cookies every day when you're fighting a weight battle isn't a good habit. I would substitute sugar free popsicles. She won't like it at first, but they grow on you and it will save her 90 calories per day. Give her 2 of them, if she wants it.

Portion control is the downfall of most American diets. 3 oz of protein is a serving. A McDonald's regular hamburger patty is 3 oz, how often do we serve a portion that small at home? A serving of starch (potatoes, rice) is usually 1/2 cup. That isn't much. Is she eating butter, ketchup, salad dressing on her food? All those calories really add up and when eaten at night it just gets stored as fat.

One of the things I do and recommend is to not eat starch after 3 pm. My dinners consist of protein and green veggies, salads with vinaigrette (no tomatoes or carrots) and sf popsicles or sf jello for dessert. I don't like low carb diets. That much protein is pretty hard on your body, but carbs are difficult to burn off after dinner. Try having her eat her carbs early in the day, when she needs the energy.

Good luck. She's lucky to have a mom that cares so much. :grouphug:
 
i think you have to look at what you, her father and other family members are like weight/body type wise.

my pediatrican worried cuz dd was too small for her age up till about age 8, now shes "too big for her age"-i can show her photos of me and i was the same way-"skinny minney" k-3, heavy 4-8, skinny again from 9th-college. no major changes in diet or physical fitness. ds is at the "skinny minney" stage now-9 yrs old next month, as tall as everyone else in his grade-and has yet to hit 50 pounds!

pediatrician/dietician suggested letting ds eat "everything a weight conscious adult would avoid" (spagetti o's, pb&j, chips, high fat/high sugar treats). my thought was "well yeah, he might put on weight but what will it do to his teeth, cholesterol, general health?".

i just go with providing as healthy snacks/meals as i can. yougurt for dd is fat free/low calorie (increased dairy products in the diet can encourage weight loss), for ds it's the regular stuff. dd eats fruit and fibar bars for breakfast, ds eats ceral, milk and a slim fast cookie dough bar.

i'm going to wait until dd hits puberty before i get too concerned about dieting. her body will be changing, and if she needs to actualy lose weight she will be at a point where she is more aware of her appearance and self motivated. as far as ds is concerned-i am not going to worry. as long as he is getting the right nutritional componants in his diet i'm not going to stress (and if he's anything like dh-it will all catch up with him within 6 months of marriage :rotfl: ).
 
I think I'd get a 2nd opinion - is she really overwieght or are the exagerating that she could be overwieght in the future if she's not careful.

Depends on her age too - some many kids go thru a "pudgy" stage around 10-12 & the begain to thin out & shoot up in height....
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom