and although we are die hard BWV fans (calling day by day at the 11 month window to be sure to get our standard view) we really really enjoyed it. I posted a very looooooooooooooong trip report about it in comparison to the BWV when we got back and if anyone is interested and hasn't seen it I can post a link to it.
About the original poster commenting on how "plain" (I think that's the word that was used) the Villas are, I don't agree at all. I'm glad that Disney didn't put in another atrium like in the main lodge. We spent plenty of time in the main building (refilling our mugs, coming back from the parks in our car, dinner at artist point, meeting friends there etc etc etc). We got to experience the grandeur and the beauty of that atrium.
Then, when we were ready to go "home" we walked across the pathway to a beautiful detailed and nicely scaled atrium. The spaces off it are warm and cozy, as are the rooms. The details in the villas, both in the public spaces and the rooms were quite wonderful and we are considering adding on there because I just fell in love. The quiet pool is just that, meant to be a quiet pool without the attraction of a slide. Again, Disney didn't duplicate what was already available but added something that was not already available there but with the same theming.
I guess if someone was expecting a copy of the WL they are going to be disappointed with the villas. I have to say, though, on our one stay at the WL (even before we bought into DVC) I was extremely disappointed with the room there (and my sister felt the same way when she visited as well) and never thought I'd stay there again. When they built the villas we decided to try it (though I was nervous) and now I am in love with the place because I have the best of both world... larger rooms with more amenities and proximity to the lodge itself and the amenities there.
Lisa
"You employ stone, wood, and concrete, and with these materials you build house and palaces. That is construction. Ingenuity is at work. But suddenly, you touch my heart, you do me good. I am happy and I say 'This is beautiful.' That is architecture. Art enters in."
-Le Corbusier