I have rented from a member of this board. I don't think there have been any problems, maybe one along time ago, when the board was new. I had a great experience with a great person. It does require some trust on both parts. What we did was exchange e-mail addresses. The owner checked availability for me, we agreed on a price and he made the ressie for me. We agreed on a deposit amount. When I received(he sent it to me) the original confirmation from BWV in my name I sent a MO for the deposit. 30 days before my trip I sent the remainder of payment. We constantly e-mailed eachother during the process. Everything worked out great.
We will definately rent again and plan to in Nov.