Well we saw it and I thought it was very well done. I went with another adult friend, DS8, DD11, & DD11's friend. DS, my friend and I loved it. The two 11 year old girls said it was "OK". Which could mean great or could mean not so good depending on the mood of the moment so I'm not sure.
Anyway, thanks for the reviews. I'm glad we went and we'll rent it on DVD for DH to see because I can tell he'll like it.