Our last trip was December 2013 & we had the most wonderful trip yet. I think like a PP said, usually the only thing people do reviews on are how bad something was. I also think a lot of people go with unrealistic expectations. They expect everything to be 'Magical!!!' And, let's face it, some things are just not.
But, I'd leave tomorrow if I could!
I totally agree with this post. I think it's a combination of factors.
As others have said, people tend to write negative posts on a chat board. Maybe 95% of their trip was just fine, but what stands out in their minds is the negative.
And Marthachick is right, some people have unrealistic expectations. Things go wrong sometimes, Disney or not! I've seen post after post about how people want their trips to be "perfect." Yikes, that just sets you up for disappointment. And, let's face it, some folks tend to see the negatives more than the positives in life, in general. I try to go with the flow whenever possible, and try not to get wigged out by the small stuff. I'm not always successful, but I try!
So, OP, please don't let the negative posts get you down. I went on a trip a year ago and had a wonderful time! I wasn't sure if I'd like FP+, but was willing to give it a whirl. When I went, you could only get 3 FP+ per day (this was before they let you get extras if they were available). While I still prefer the legacy FP system by far, I can see some of the benefits of the new system, and have adapted. I didn't notice a decline in CM service, I didn't see any dirty bathrooms, and I thought the food was just fine! We had some great CM interactions and loved our Lion King Suite. It's funny, I saw some posts just before I left where people were complaining about cracked floor tiles in the main building at AoA. I thought, "Wow, if that's the type of thing you're focusing on, you'll probably have a miserable trip!"
Was I 100% happy with our trip? No, but I was 97% happy!!! We had a great time, and I'm definitely planning to return as soon as I can swing it. I urge you to try another trip - I bet you'll have a great time.