Here are my views on FP+ from someone who rarely gets a chance to go to WDW but is a big planner for such things:
1) We all understand that those of us that do significant planning months and months in advance are a very small minority of WDW visitors. And out of the planners, I've only seen a small percentage of those folks openly embrace the FP+ system. Which means it is an EXTREMELY small group of people excited by FP+. If you think it's a giant PITA for those that like to plan, what will families that do very little planning think of the new system? Not only will they have not booked their FP+ for attractions ahead of time but the chance to use normal FP
may be gone when you arrive at the park in the future. What a "magical" experience that will be for lots of people. Way to win back potentially repeat customers Disney.
2) Any level of spontaneity during your trip will be significantly impacted, ESPECIALLY if you visit during busier times of year. It's one thing to have some sort of touring plan in mind and executed, it's quite another when normal FP may not be available or return times are hours and hours out.
3) As others have stated, made your ADRs 180 days out so you can eat at a special place in a particular park or resort. Well now that it is time to make your 60 day FP+ reservations you find that you can only pick a general time of day, morning, afternoon, evening. Well your ADR isn't for "evening", it's for 6:40PM EXACTLY. If your FP+ reservation if for a nearby attraction at 6:15pm you might be ok, but what if you get one for 6:45pm instead? And dinner runs to past 7:40PM cause your table wasn't ready. You just LOST your FP+. WINNING!!!! With normal FP you can at least see when the return times are for an attraction and decide then if that time works for you, with FP+ that is not the case since you got them ahead of time with a more general time frame.
4) As others have stated, "If it's not broke, don't fix it." I realize that Disney is attempting to get people out of attraction lines so they can spend more money on food, clothing, souveniers, etc. However, let' be honest. People on the whole are NOT going to WDW ONLY to eat over-priced food or buy expensive things to take back home. They are going to enjoy the attractions for the most part, especially the once in a lifetime guests. So for those guests they will be miserable waiting hours in stand-by lines for a couple attractions, they will NOT be spending extra money as Disney predicts, at least not IMHO.
Granted it is still not fully implemented as of yet and some things are still unknown, but so far the reports that show people like the system is tainted because those guests have been able to use BOTH FP systems. A true test would be to have guests that opt to be part of the FP+ Test be restricted to ONLY those FP+ reservations they made ahead of time and they are not able to pull any other FP for that day. That would provide a much more accurate test of what FP+ truly entails and THEN we can see how wonderful the new system is. See how it impacts people's ADRs or how they tour the parks.
I don't mind change when it improves an inefficient, broken system. But when it involves complicating a system that seems to work pretty well, my logical brain simply can't grasp the desire to make that change. It would be really nice to have some Disney executive clearly spell out not only how they envision FP+ will work for everyday WDW guests, but how it really improves on the existing FP system. Cause for the life of me, I simply don't see it for 95% of all WDW guests.
