I'll second the recommendation for Lisa at Lisa's Magical Weddings. She recently did my hair and make up for my vow renewal, and I was very pleased with both.
My hair isn't very long (an up-do wasn't an option) so I brought several photos of my usual style which Lisa recreated--with a bit more oomph! I'd strongle suggest you have photos to show exactly what you're envisioning, no matter what hair length or style you're going for.
As for make-up, not only did I love what Lisa did for the ceremony, but I found a new, favorite mascara. I tend not to wear mascara as if flakes and bothers my eyes, but LOVED the one Lisa used.
Good luck!