I had fun tracking them down! At MGM the 5 $ 10 store is supposed to have them (there is a monograming area to the left of the door) but they were out of them. At MK, no one knew what they were even after I pointed their own name tags out to them! I asked in one store and was sent to city hall. they sent me to the firestation and another store. CLUELESS! Where I did find it finally (and thank you to those that posted on this site) was at Marketplace (Downtown Disney)-the Christmas Shop has a monograming area at the back of this store. They only had a few left when I was there last month. I think they ran about $6/$8 and took about 5-10 minutes to make. They seem a bit flimsy too. On the back is a clip and a safety pin.
I just ordered my kids' some from giftsofalifetime.com A bit of a markup, but they still have the "old" red, Mickey version and the service was quick. WDW is coming out with new characters on a badge made of different (cheaper?) material; if you want a red Mickey, this may be your best option. I received mine in 10 days. Good Luck!
They have them at the World of Disney store in Downtown Disney with no names on them so you just take them to the Days of Christmas store to have your name put on them. They also have them at the 5 & 10 cent store at Disney Studios and they will put the names on right there. I also found some at the Premium Outlets Mall that already had some common names on them for $1.99! I found a Scott and bought it, even though I already have one! You can also buy keychains ect. and have them monogramed at the Days of Christmas store very cheaply. I think we paid $3.00 to have a name put on a keychain. They also will sew on your name and Mickey ears on each side on a pin lanyard at the 5 & 10 cent store at Disney studios for I think it was $8.00. Looked really nice, although I didn't buy one.
Thanks for the information. We bought ours last January, and then bought more for our niece and nephew in August. I'm glad I did. The quality of the new ones doesn't sound very impressive.
Does anyone know if they have a Stitch or a Minnie Mouse name tag at Disney World? I would love to get one if they do! I already have a red Mickey Mouse one from Disneyland. So it would be nice to have one from Disney World too. Thanks.