Do you mind telling me about this place? My Dh and I are doing a non-kid trip in early Sept for our anniversay to do things we can't do when we have the kids with us. Pleasure Island is specifically what we had planned but I have never heard of Adventurer's club.
My wife and I were only there twice (on the same trip) back in '98 "pre-kids". We were never big fans of dance clubs, but we thought we would try DTD and check out all the venues since one admission covered all the clubs. Our plan was to try out the AC and Comedy Warehouse - and then the dance clubs. Never happened. We went into the AC first, and stayed until last call - and did the same thing on the second visit to DTD.
We didn't get to go in '06, but we will be going with another couple and their child this August, and since we've agree to babysit for each other to allow for a "couples" night out - we'll make sure we go again this time.
Anyway, the Adventurer's Club closing is getting so much negative feedback because it is really the only uniquely Disney nightspot. Some, and I agree with this, go so far as to say it is like no other nightclub anywhere, let alone Disney World. It's actually more of an attraction - there are audio anamatronics throughout - from talking pictures on the wall to barstools that go up and down at (I think) random. On top of all this, you have a troupe of actors who put on comedy routines throughout the night - often grabbing people from the audience to take part. Even when the shows aren't going on, the cast wander around as "Club Members" interacting with the patrons - it's essentially improv, but rather than shouting out ideas, the cast simply responds to whatever you say to them.
Some of it can be pretty cheesy - but my wife and I thought it was hilarious. Generally, people either love the place or think it's dumb - there's very little in between. In terms of the two extremes, I think more people like it than not.
When the club opens, the interactions are pretty much PG - but after 10:30 pm or so, it moves into PG-13 territory - mostly innuendos, or the French Maid standing over top of gentlemen and bending over to dust one of the statues - putting what is revealed by her low-cut uniform at eye level. Usually, this is accompanied by her saying, "Oh, excusez-moi monsieur - I 'ope you don't mind, but I must dust zee bust" - or something like that.
At some point during the evening, they have a ceremony to make all the guests honourary memeber of the club. The slogan at the end is "If you come in here a stranger, you will exit as a friend". However, there is a sign somewhere that twists this - "Come in a stranger, leave a little stranger".
If you allow yourself to get caught up in the moments - both sentences will be true.