Grocery Shopping prices

Edd

<a href="http://www.wdwinfo.com/dis-sponsor/" targ
Joined
May 21, 2006
Messages
3,873
Here are the prices at the Walmart closest to Disney for a list set up by one disboard member.

Walmart:

Case (24) Dasani water $4.98

12 Pack of Coke 2.98

Gallon Milk (TG Lee) 2.44

Micro Pop Corn (Pop Weaver 15) 2.77

Pop Tarts 1.67

Large Chips (lays) 2.00

Cheerios (15 oz) 2.68

6 pack Bud (longnecks) 4.94

Box of Capri Sun (10 packs) 1.82

Fruit - Apples (big Red McIntosh) 1.37


Publix aqnd gooding to follow shortly.
 
kay.... in the other thread posted
Ooh, can I start?

Goodings $46.46 + $20 delivery (actual minimum $50, but the items not priced online would bring the order above that):
1) Case of Dasani water $15.96 (four 6-packs Zephyrhills)
2) Suitcase (12 pack) of coke cans. $4.69
3) Gallon of milk. $5.98 (two half-gallons)
4) microwave pop corn $3.29 (Orville Redenbacher 3-pack)
5) Pop-Tarts $3.19 (8-pack)
6) large bag of chips $2.99 (Lay's 12.5 oz.)
7) Large box of Cheerios $4.99 (15 oz)
8) 6 pack of Bud (N/A)
9) pack of apple juice boxes (not on price list, but ANY item in store is available for delivery
10) fruit--either apples or banana $5.37 (3 pound @ $1.79/pound)

Garden Grocer $36.41 + $10 delivery (currently no minimum):
1) Case of Dasani water $7.99 (24 pack)
2) Suitcase (12 pack) of coke cans. $4.79
3) Gallon of milk. $3.79
4) microwave pop corn $2.99
5) Pop-Tarts $2.29
6) large bag of chips $2.99 (11.5oz)
7) Large box of Cheerios $4.29
8) 6 pack of Bud
9) pack of apple juice boxes $3.19 (9-pack 6.75 oz Mott's) $3.45 (10pack 6.75 oz Minute Maid)
10) fruit--either apples or banana $3.99 (3 pounds = $1.33/pound)

Most of the towncar companies don't want to stop at Wal Mart. I'm curious how Publix, Hess mini-mart and even the resorts stores compare.
 
My goodness, what kind of cows do they have in Florida for milk to be $5 a gallon?? !
 
Maybe I made a mistake on the price. I might have doubled the price of a gallon. I usually don't buy much milk. It might have priced a gallon thinking it was a half a gallon. I am not to domesticated.
 

So the difference in the Walmart prices and gardengrocer not including the price on beer and maybe a few small changes in Popcorn and fruit is $11.00 more at gardengrocer plus $10.00 delivery charge. That is a total of $21.00 in just that small list. Wonder what the difference would be if you spent $200.00 for groceries?
 
No, Garden Grocer's delivery charge is $10, not $20.
The difference if you spent $200 for groceries is $0. $200 = $200 = $200.

Currently:
WalMart: $30.09 + $100 for town car + $20 mandatory tip = $150.09
Garden Grocer: $36.41 + $10 delivery (plus six-pack price, not provided, let's say $7.50) + free DME ride to resort = $53.91
Goodings: $46.46 + $20 delivery + (again, estimated) $7.50 for beer and $3 for juice boxes + free DME ride to resort = $76.96
WeGoShop (estimated) will shop wherever you request, so let's say WalMart: $30.09 + $17 delivery = $47.09 (except WeGoShop has, I think $50 minimum, so $67)
 
I know Edd is a "promoter" of town car service but don't just think that way. Some town car companies will give a grocery stop for one way trips, some charge some are free. Guests can rent a car for a day, less than $50, and shop wherever they want.

It sure looks like paying to rent a car or even paying for a one way towncar trip might be cheaper than using Goodings delivery service. I think a typical guest is going to be buying more than the ten items on my list.

I think wegoshop might be the way to go. It's confirmed that Goodings is as expensive as we thought.



kaytieeldr said:
No, Garden Grocer's delivery charge is $10, not $20.
The difference if you spent $200 for groceries is $0. $200 = $200 = $200.

Currently:
WalMart: $30.09 + $100 for town car + $20 mandatory tip = $150.09
Garden Grocer: $36.41 + $10 delivery (plus six-pack price, not provided, let's say $7.50) + free DME ride to resort = $53.91
Goodings: $46.46 + $20 delivery + (again, estimated) $7.50 for beer and $3 for juice boxes + free DME ride to resort = $76.96
WeGoShop (estimated) will shop wherever you request, so let's say WalMart: $30.09 + $17 delivery = $47.09 (except WeGoShop has, I think $50 minimum, so $67)
 
I am thinking of trying Garden Grocer. (The whole Wegoshop mess last winter kind of scared me off. I know it's a new owner and all, but....)

The other thing is I like the ease of the Garden Grocer website as opposed to the Wegohop method. (And even if I rent a car going to those Walmarts near Disney just is too much for me... I can do the Publix, but not the Walmart. The few times I have been in them it's just been crazy. Of course I don't shop Walmart at home either so...)
 
You talk about how busy Wal Mart is and I think there are many hours it is not. It is open 24 hours. You can hate WalMart all you want but it does have the best brands, a wide variety of goods and very clean stores. Actually their meat is about the best in the business. As you will see their prices are very good. I am glad I don't have a big family and some of the attitudes I have noted in these boards. Buying groceries for a big family could save you a ton of money at Wal Mart.
 
Edd said:
You talk about how busy Wal Mart is and I think there are many hours it is not. It is open 24 hours. You can hate WalMart all you want but it does have the best brands, a wide variety of goods and very clean stores. Actually their meat is about the best in the business. As you will see their prices are very good. I am glad I don't have a big family and some of the attitudes I have noted in these boards. Buying groceries for a big family could save you a ton of money at Wal Mart.


HUH? (And by the way I once went to a WalMart in Kissimee at 11:30 PM... It was PACKED with folks. I was trying to print some digital photos for a DIS meet the next day and the place was just crazy.) I am sure that there are hours when it isn't crowded, but somehow grocery shopping at Disney at 2 AM doesn't really appeal to me (YMMV) :rotfl2:


However, I find that at least here, the WalMarts are not dramatically cheaper then the local grocery stores. (Maybe Orlando is different) They all cross shop each other which keeps them honest.
 
Just a few things to ponder....I'm on vacation, I'm not cooking. Yes, there are usually some things I would rather get in Florida, rather than bring them with me. But, the total is usually very low...a loaf of bread, some water, chips, milk, half and half. Everything else I bring with me. Why? Because two times now, with two different companies (and yes, they were/are well known companies) I have not gotten the grocery stop. Well, to be completely honest, the first time I did, sort of. Our flight was over 2 hrs late and our driver, Don (with TT) asked if we minded using a convienience store. No big deal, we went without some stuff. The other time, and I've related this story before, was Thanksgiving and despite being told about 4 times by the office, when I asked them, our driver told me no stores were open on Thanksgiving morning. Find that hard to believe. So, for me..I take no chances anymore. I have whatever I need, delivered. I'm sure my experiences are not all that common, but still, they happened.
 
Lewis,

I am surprised you think I promote the town cars. I have not actually promoted anyone on these boards. I stick up for the all the independent transportation because they have to survive also. I have put down some of the town car practices, also. I am actually a Disney fan from way back and probably have been to and around Disney more than 99 of you people on the boards. I do not promote the DME because I feel it is unfair to promote that service as free. That is an unfair competitive edge. I suppose if a theropeutic sevice promote their work as free in Atlantic City they would capture the majority of the business. Actually that goes for any business. Proof of my statement would be if Disney started charging the old Mears rate for transportation to Disney, the ridership would fall off drastically.

Disney is great for the Orlando area and we love our tourists, but even some of the greatest things or persons we experience can sometimes get overbearing. Someday. let me tell you about my mother who is long time gone.
 
Edd,
I agree that you have not promoted a "particular" towncar, but from the tone of your posts it's pretty apparent that you think a towncar is the way to go..

I agree that for some folks it is a great choice, for others a not so great choice. I have a group of 8 going to Disney the end of August. We discussed Towncar, rental car and DME. We got great deals on full size car and a mini van which in total are going to cost less then the town car. (Three different return trips are needed) That also gives us some flexibility we wouldn't have with Disney transport only. (Including the grocery stop at Publix, the ablity to restock at will etc.)
 
goofy4tink said:
Just a few things to ponder....I'm on vacation, I'm not cooking. Yes, there are usually some things I would rather get in Florida, rather than bring them with me. But, the total is usually very low...a loaf of bread, some water, chips, milk, half and half. Everything else I bring with me.
When I got a Gooding's delivery last year, much of my order was refrigerated stuff, like milk, yogurt, cheese sticks, deli American cheese, cream cheese (to go on the bagels), plus some fresh fruit like grapes and bananas that wouldn't travel well.

And by the way, Gooding's was already expensive, but now that they upped their delivery charge from $10 to $20 I'm probably going to be a Garden Grocer customer come November.
 
Edd said:
I do not promote the DME because I feel it is unfair to promote that service as free. That is an unfair competitive edge. I suppose if a theropeutic sevice promote their work as free in Atlantic City they would capture the majority of the business. Actually that goes for any business.
Not the first time you've confused Lewis and me (I'm the therapist from the Atlantic City area), which is understandable because of the strong physical resemblence. :lmao:

Anyway, as I wrote last year, my industry underwent a HUGE shake-up a few years after I started in it. Before managed care, a physician wrote a prescription or an order and the insurance company paid for it, no negotiation, no argument, and certainly no second-guessing. Nowadays, you have 23 year old liberal arts graduates (insurance company claims adjusters) making MEDICAL DECISIONS that counteract the therapeutic orders given by experienced and licensed physicians. TALK ABOUT UNFAIR!!! As a result, my industry changed DRASTICALLY, pretty much overnight, not unlike the car service industry around WDW post-DME.

Prior to managed care, we provided good treatment, but we were also kind of fat and lazy up to that time. We weren't too concerned about how long it took us to produce results because the insurance companies HAD TO pay us; and even though the ethical among us didn't do this on purpose, the longer it took us to help someone out, the more we got paid.

But then managed care came in. All of a sudden the doctors couldn't order the insurance companies to write us a blank check. Many medical rehab providers went out of business because they couldn't adapt to the new environment. A few, like the one I work for, have actually thrived in this new environment. The treatment we provide our patients is quicker, more cost efficient, and it turns out it's also better for the patient! We are able to rehab them faster, which means they get well sooner and get back into their real life quicker than they would have 15 years ago. My company now earns money from repeat business -- insurance comapnies know that we produce good results (which keeps their customers, our patients, happy), so they throw more business our way the next time they have a need for our services.

For us, it's a different way of thinking and of doing business, but we're succeeding in this harsh environment because we've adapted rather than whined and complained.

I see the same thing for the car service industry around MCO. Yes, some will go out of business, which really sucks for the entrepreneurs and good employees who did nothing but do their jobs as best they could. The companies (and individuals) who will survive are those who will adapt to the new environment. They'll highlight the benefits of a private car service, and possibly market more towards a slightly more affluent crowd and less towards the budget-conscious set.

So yes, Edd, I know EXACTLY what it's like to wake up one day and have my livelihood threatened. I lived the adventure. I also suffered the indignity (to them, not to me) of others coming to me looking for jobs, people who had more professional education and more experience coming to me asking to work under my supervision, because my company survived and their company or hospital didn't. Thank goodness my boss, our company's owner, is brilliant and saw a way to steer us into the New World.
Edd said:
Disney is great for the Orlando area and we love our tourists, but you even some of the greatest things or persons we experience can sometimes get overbearing. Someday. let me tell you about my mother who is long time gone.
Edd, nice to see a sense of humor peek out! I'm certain you have one in real life, but you've never honored us with it before.
 
Publix is comparable with Wal Mart on most items. If I don't need a lot of stuff I just shop at Publix or if I just need groceries and not other items.
 
CleveRocks said:
Edd, nice to see a sense of humor peek out! I'm certain you have one in real life, but you've never honored us with it before.

I don't know Edd from Addam, but I already think he's funny:


Maybe I made a mistake on the price. I might have doubled the price of a gallon. I usually don't buy much milk. It might have priced a gallon thinking it was a half a gallon. I am not to domesticated.

"Not too domesticated" made me LOL!

PS: Hi CarolA!
 
CarolA

No, I don't think town car is the only way to go. There are many other choices. DME is not your choice either. I wonder why. I don't buy your reasoning. You must think the same way as you are planning on renting a vehicle on your next trip when you could ride the DME. It certainly looks like you are having 3 different returns to the airport which will cost gas when you could ride the DME free of charge both ways. You could rent a daily rental if you have other things to do.
 
Cleve Rocks,

I did not confuse Lewis with you. I wasn't speaking to you. I believe I addressed Lewis at the beginning of the statements.

I believe I have read your life and work history before on some of these boards.
 
Edd said:
Cleve Rocks,

I did not confuse Lewis with you. I wasn't speaking to you. I believe I addressed Lewis at the beginning of the statements.

I believe I have read your life and work history before on some of these boards.
Yes, you did address your post to Lewis, but giving an example to Lewis of therapy in Atlantic City was a confusing choice, hence my assumption that you were confusing the two of us. It was just an odd choice for an example.

And yes, you read my history, as you put it, at least on another board, which is why I mentoined something in my post about you reading it last year.

I actually DO understand what individuals like you have been going through with the advent of DME, because I went through exactly the same thing. Before I was insulted and ridiculed in the past by you (and some others elsewhere) because I am a satisfied DME customer, I repeatedly tried to HELP by suggesting that people and companies in your position change focus and market yourselves differently, rather than simply complain about and trash DME.

By your (written) tone in the recent past it is evident you have come to see the wisdom of that method (regardless of how you came to realize it), and I think it's made the DISboards a better place for people to learn ALL of their options.
:disrocks:
 














Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top