Well, I've stayed at both the Polynesian Concierge Lagoon View and the Grand Floridian Lagoon View. I think the view from the Grand Floridian was better. The MK is closer, so I guess that's why I thought so. I liked having concierge service at the Polynesian, but I think I'd still rather stay at the Grand Floridian without the concierge service. At the Grand Floridian, all rooms do get robes, turndown service, and minibars - so it is in a respect similar to concierge (w/o the lounge).