mdsouth
DIS Veteran
- Joined
- Jan 15, 2005
- Messages
- 3,120
3G vs. wifi
OK, I picked wifi only specifically because of these reasons:
1. We have wifi set up at home so there's no reason why I would need a 3G coverage
2. We DON'T have any 3G AT&T coverage in our area
3. I don't travel so much that I would frequently need to have a 3G coverage for a must-download-book moment
4. I purchased Nook for 90% library books. So I sideload most of my books.
5. If I'm in a pinch, McDonalds around me (8mi down the road though) has AT&T wifi I could use.
and of course
6. The price... 25% less than 3G.
My reasons are not techie reasons by any means... hopefully that helps.![]()
Thanks, cseca! This is basically what I have been thinking myself. I plan to use my library a lot for downloads and expect to do most of my downloads at home. I, too, travel very little so that is not a great factor in my decision.
I have a Kindle. Wi Fi requires a hot spot for you to download. 3G allows you to download anywhere that is covered by the 3G network. For example, I would not think that sitting on a beach you would find a free Wifi hotspot but you would likely find 3G.
What you need to consider is if you care if you are restricted to hot spots or plugging into a computer to download.
Because my Kindle came with 3G, I am spoiled. I think I would always want that option.
Jrmasm, thanks! You have given me several things to consider. I first have to figure out what the 3G AT&T coverage is in my area. I like the idea of being able to download a book anywhere I am instead of waiting to get home or find a Wi-Fi hot spot.
If I was purchasing now, I'd definitely go with the wi-fi only. I purchased a Nook about six weeks ago, right before the new options came out. My nook was updated so it's now 3G compatible, but I don't see myself using that option.
The only place I use wi-fi is at home...AND it's $50 cheaper!!![]()
SaraJayne, you have brought up an important point. Thanks! The bargain hunter is definitely looking at the fact that it is indeed $50.00 cheaper.
I have a couple of different digital readers but my favorite is my Kindle. Why do I prefer 3G?
Like the pp I actually do most of my book buying at my house and the WiFi would be just fine for that. But I do use the 3G just enough that I'm glad I have it and consider it worth the $40. Besides, a good deal of the fun of these toys is instant book buying no matter where you are...in the car, stuck at your kid's baseball tournament...waiting at the doctor's office... The 3G expands that considerably.
RitaE thanks for your ideas. Your ideas are key points I need to consider.
The reason I am buying an ereader is for fun! It is not a necessity for me. I just think it would be nice to have access to lots of books anywhere I am. So, your reasoning about being able to get a new book download whereever I am - waiting to pick up my kids from a school activity, dance, the doctor's office, etc. is probably the biggest reason why I am even considering the 3G option. Otherwise, I would just go with the cheaper version and use the extra $50.00 to buy some ebooks or magazine subscriptions.
Oh, the dilema.
I truly thank everyone for their opinions on the issue.

You all offered very valid points that I will have to consider further.
First, I think I am going to investigate the Wi-Fi hot spots and 3G coverage in my area before I make the final decision.

I just found a new reason to love my nook 
I had my Nook in my purse. I got it out, went to the store, let the kids search for kids titles, then quickly and quietly bought and downloaded a copy of a Magic Treehouse book and a Flat Stanley book. It was AWESOME. The kids figured out how to use it in seconds. Flashlight in hand they were reading, and happy and not restless any more. We were able to get thru the rest of the ceremony with no problems.
On the way home the 10 yo asked if he could get his own Nook. 
bump