Good Carbs vs. Bad Carbs

DisneyKing82

Mouseketeer
Joined
Jul 7, 2009
Messages
212
If anyone is really into health and wants to add to this list, would be much appreciated. Trying to work on my eating habits, especially when it comes to carbs.

Good Carbs
Brown Rice
Baked Potatoes
Whole Grain Breads, Rye Bread

Bad Carbs
White Rice
White Flour Breads
 
If anyone is really into health and wants to add to this list, would be much appreciated. Trying to work on my eating habits, especially when it comes to carbs.

Good Carbs
Brown Rice
Baked Potatoes
Whole Grain Breads, Rye Bread

Bad Carbs
White Rice
White Flour Breads

You know, even the baked potato could be considered a 'bad carb' if it's a big honking sized one. Potato servings should be rather small.

No sugar, either. Add that to your list.

Beans are excellent good carbs.
 
just a reminder, a baked potato is an EXCELLENT source of potassium! Eat one as big as you want!
 
just a reminder, a baked potato is an EXCELLENT source of potassium! Eat one as big as you want!
 

Baked potato has a very high glycemic index and is on my list of "bad carbs". I do indulge in a small one once in a while but generally try to avoid.

Nuts and seeds are generally good. So are high fiber, whole grain cereals.
 
Good Carbs - high in fiber - have a low glycemic index - fresh fruits & veggies - esp. those high in fiber ( sweet potatoes, leafy greens, berries) - legumes - lentils - seeds - nuts

Bad Carbs - highly refined & processed foods (packaged crackers/ cookies/ chips/ soda)

as already mentioned whole grain breads & pastas vs the white processed counterparts.
 
Really I think it comes down to this....take a high-carb food and ask yourself how close it is to its natural state. Potato is a good example - that baked potato is a heck of a lot better than a potato chip.

One that does confuse me is corn. Fresh corn - how bad can that be? (not that I care, I'm eating it anyway)
 
The more fiber and less refined the grain the better. The worst carbs are sugars. Refined sugar is pretty much nutritionally useless. This goes for Splenda and all the other sugar substitutes also. I don't have any sweetener in my house at all. If I did it would be pure Stevia.

Most fruits and vegetables are good carbs. Potatoes area a tricky one. They have a high GI number and those are not generally good. If you are looking to lose weight I would stay away from them. A smaller one from time to time (with not butter or sour cream or anything else fastening) isn't bad. If you are trying to maintain weight you have a little more leeway. A good substitute texture wise is celery root (celeriac). It has a potato-like texture and feel with a bit of a celery flavor. Same goes with parsnips. There is a Good Eats episode called Celeryman (S12E02) that talks about celery and celeriac and one called Undercover Veggies (S13E05) that does some parsnip recipes.

The most important thing to do is read the label. If the sugar content is high or fiber levels low it is probably not a very good carb. If Inulin is an agreement you have to know that the grams of fiber are inflated. Inulin isn't bad but the effect it has on health is different than other types of fiber. It is often added for marketing so that they can put a bigger fiber number on the front of the box in the hopes you won't look at the back.
 
being a diabetic I have attended quite a few classes on eating healthy. While I am not a wheat person, I do indulge once a month in pasta of my choice. A baked potato may be considered a bad carb but it is also considered a good carb because it is a natural food item. Some veggies are high in carbs but are still considered a good choice when making them.
I love pistachios and those are good ......just attended my twice a year visit with the dietician and she said I am on the right track. sometimes denying yourself a bad choice of carbs is as bad as eating them all the time..
on the corn on the cob issue........half of a large ear is 14 carbs and it is a treat to have once in a while......carrots, peas, are high in carbs but good carbs...
a good book to have is called the
Calorie King ..it contains all the food items and drink items ever and has the listing for fats, calories and carbs.....it is recommended by the diabetic association..also has restaurants and cs food items....
 
Baked potato is bad--sweet potato is good. (despite it's name! But in moderation!)



Things I ate while I could do the good carb thing (on a hiatus due to morning sickness and my body has a problem digesting the more complex "good" cards.)

Beans--most kinds (kidney, garbanzo, black beans) have carbs in them.


And I had veggies every meal with exception of carrots and corn (sugars, and technically not a good carb depending on your reasons for going good carb).


So part of going good carb--is getting other good non-carb foods up in your diet as well.

I limited my fruits to 2-3 a day though and for things like apples and pears I had it with Almond butter or peanut butter.

I followed south beach phase 2 which was reasonable. You can still indulge, but once you get used to the lower gylcemic way of eating, you will notice that you don't need as much of an indulgance (sp?).
 
I just started the Food Lovers Fat Loss System. (www.myfoodlovers.com -- there is a message board there too) They teach you that there aren't good or bad carbs. Its what you eat with what. Each meal should have a fast carb, a slow carb, and protein. And we snack every 2 hours between meals & until bedtime.

Its not a diet. You can eat anything, with some modification in switching brands due to ingredients in the food.

But its really all about eating a BALANCED meal. Something you can do for life.
 
Something to remember is each person's body will process food items differently. So, a potato may spike my BG higher than another person's, therefore I would (and do) avoid them. Pasta, even whole wheat (although a bit better) is the same.

Dark green vegetables, those of the cruciform group (broccoli, cauliflower, etc) onions, tomatoes, those are all easy on the blood glucose. And yes, that is what you want to control to lose weight, not be hungry, and avoid numerous other issues.

Adding some healthy fat to higher carb choices will slow down the absorbtion and the resulting BG spike.

The glycemic index is an indicator, but not a g-d, eh? :) Use it to determine what the better choices are for you, not dictate.

For me an apple is better than carrots. Again, it's the individual metabolic process.

Attempting to follow any nutritional approach without understanding how any given food causes your body to respond is going to cause problems.

Rye bread is better for you than white bread, that sort of thing. Look for stone ground wheat, not wheat flour, as the primary ingredient. Remember that ingredients are listed in order of amount, with the first in the list being the ingredient that the item has the most of. ::yes::

Ask questions, read labels, and don't buy things that can't be defined. I was in a bakery recently and asked about the bread and the worker couldn't answer the questions, so I couldn't buy the bread.

Good luck to you. Getting healthier through eating is a fun challenge!
 












Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top