We seriously looked at the Highlander, Acadia, and Pilot. We liked the Highlander alot but it was last year when Toyota was having so many recall issues and they actually halted sales a few days after we test drove it, so that took it off of our list. The Acadia was nice enough, my biggest like was the captains chairs in the backseat as opposed to a bench. We had previously had a Tahoe and were just satisfied with it, not in love with it & the dealerships were not making any movements on the pricing at all. I didn't love the feel of the ride either.
We ended up both loving the Pilot which is amazing, since I am 5'3 and dh is a former linebacker at 6'1, so he needs lots of shoulder and leg room & I need very little, but good vision lines with few blind spots. The pilot has a smoother drive imo & lots of nice features. I really like that even with the 3rd row of seats up there is still ample trunk space & they are easily put up and down & when they are down the trunk is HUGE. The cupholders are also awesome (which is key for a big coffee drinker). Can't say enough good things about my pilot!!
We