The odd thing is that only 3 were less per Sq Ft because they were forclosures the others were comparable cost per sq foot. To explain further since dropping $20,000 we are quite a bit lower per sq ft than the others in the area that are similar to ours. Two within about a mile, one a forclosure and one that was similar to our house but more per sq ft have sold within the last 3 months. I am almost wondering if when we dropped the $20,000 at the new realtors advise it didn't make other realtors worry there was something wrong with our house? I am just baffled about it all. Oh and we were told the average selling time for homes in our area is 6 months.
The good and bad thing about the market these days is that anyone can see your listing - no one is dependent on a realtor to tell them it exists. So while a realtor might think a drop means an issue (though in this market it's so common I'd think that wasn't a likely assumption, given how often price drops occur when something doesn't sell), if your house is in the MLS, people can see the listing.
I'd really begin to think there's an issue with the house, given the $ comps are apparently in line. It's hard but ... again, anyone can see the listing and if other things are priced comparably or higher and are legit selling... there has to be a reason and what's kind of left is the house itself.
Are the other homes for sale/that sold more upgraded? Do you have the same sq. footage but fewer bedrooms or something? Or is your house smaller or larger overall? Do you have a thing like a pool that people may be turned off by? Is your house on a different or strange plot of land? Like on a busier street or a lot that backs onto a highway or I dunno. Do others have a garage and you don't, do they have new appliances and you don't, do they have hardwood and you have carpet, etc., etc.
Have you gone into any local comps or checked pics and descriptions of other listings around you to try and figure it out? How are the pics with your listing? Do they highlight the house? Do they show clutter or are they dark or etc.? Do they show the kitchen and bath and etc.?