Assuming I get a chance to go back to Disney anytime soon - I'd probably buy the individual attraction choice for ROTR on a HS day. Beyond that, I'm not sure yet. I rarely want to "be on my phone all day to maximize ride access." If I was looking for a day to hit a lot of rides, I might buy
Genie+ that day. Prior to Covid, I was a frequent solo traveler "just for me to get away from work" and have some fun. I didn't need to maximize my enjoyment of attractions.
When I'm ready to return, I'm not sure....... paying for something that was free still stings right now. Probably would on family trips as during those - hitting the rides is often a key goal!