GBOATT Rankings

MuNkY

Momma don't cry. I just wanna stay high.
Joined
Aug 22, 2005
Messages
5,560
Alright, this is how I am ranking bands. Whoever gets the highest score gets the highest seed. I'm figuring the scores off of a formula. This is the formula.

*Ammount of records + *sum of record sales / *years as a band = score

*Ammount of Records
This is pretty simple. Every Album that the band has produced, will be added up here. I'm only counting albums that are solely the band. For example, Velvet Revolver has made Contraband, but they have also been featured on several soundtracks. I'm not counting the soundtracks they are featured on, only Contraband. I'm also including greatest hits albums.


*Sum of Record Sales
This is where things get a little more complicated. I'll be awarding points based off of how well a certain record did. If a record went gold, then it will get a certain ammount of points. Platinum, it will get some more points, and so on. Also it's only including US sales, so it may be hindered a little bit. The allocation of points is as follows...

Gold: 20 pts.
Platinum: 25 pts.

I'll also be giving an extra 5 points for every time a record goes multi-platinum. So for example, lets look at one album. Motley Crue's Dr. Feelgood album.

First it went gold. Thats 20 points. Then it went Platinum, 25 more points. Then it went multiplatinum 5 times, so thats an additional 25 points. Altogether, Dr. Feelgood would have earned Motley Crue 70 points.


*Years as a Band
Simple really. I'll take 2006, and subtract it by the year the band formed. Not quite 100% effective, but it'll do.


So lets look at this whole formula in action. Once again, I'll use Motley Crue.

15 Albums + 405 points earned from album sales / 24 years as a band = 17.5 points

Once again, thats 15 + 405 / 24 = 17.5





Now understand I have to figure this out for every single band on the list. Thats 50 bands, where I have to go through discographies, figure out points, figure out how many years as a band, do the formula for each and every band, and then figure out how they rank. So it may take a week or two, but then we can get this party rolling. :smokin:
 
Wow. YOu are going through aa lot of work for this. YOu should do a report about it/ "The Dis Boards Opinions of Bands" That would be fun to turn in for a project.:)
 
disneydramadiva said:
Wow. YOu are going through aa lot of work for this. YOu should do a report about it/ "The Dis Boards Opinions of Bands" That would be fun to turn in for a project.:)
Just trying to keep it as fair as possible. The way the formula is designed is to keep bands on as even a playing field as possible.

I remember I saw this same thing on another board, and the way it was done, was in the order the bands were suggested. The reason behind seeding is to have great late round match-ups. We ended up with stuff like AC/DC against Van Halen in the second round. This way, that won't happen. Or at least it shouldn't.
 

Loves Disney said:
Just because you mentioned that, lol, watch as it ends up Van Halen against AC/DC lol. :rolleyes:
Lol. Yeah.
 
Just as an update, I'm about a quarter of the way through figuring the field.
 
Wow, Mike! You're putting a lot of work into this! Can't wait to see the scores :thumbsup2
 
Cinderella94 said:
Wow, Mike! You're putting a lot of work into this! Can't wait to see the scores :thumbsup2
You won't be seeing the scores, but you'll be seeing the seedings.
 
While I'm at it, anybody care to guess who the #1 seed will be? The #50?
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom