Hello! I've been lurking for several days even though our week will probably be excluded in Free Dining. This is only tangentially related to this thread, but this thread has kind of gone everywhere now. So listen to this.
A month or so ago, we thought we were going the first week in October, so I started running the numbers at different resorts. Well, at a huge number of deluxe resorts (almost all of them...I have a list somewhere) there were zero standard, garden, pool, preferred, etc. rooms left. Absolutely zero. And really, I think it was all the deluxe resorts and some of the villas. The only rooms left were the suites.
I chatted with Disney and they said to clear my cache and try again, which I did. Still no rooms. Then they said it's a popular week because of the Not-So-Scary Halloween and the Food & Wine Festival.
I just don't believe that every single Deluxe Hotel could already be full. They must be holding the rooms for something, don't you think? It's all weird. I haven't tried recently because our trip got moved to the second week in October. But I thought it was very curious.
I think it's possible they are full. The deluxe resorts don't have as much capacity as the other resorts, and BC/YC and Poly are renovating right now. We booked YC several months ago, and our TA said there weren't very many rooms left then.